prep2-123

cyang16

Vivien Thomas, who had no formal medical training, in struggling against overwhelming odds, he became a cardiac surgeon and eventually to receive an honorary doctorate from Johns Hopkins University.    

(A) who had no formal medical training, in struggling against overwhelming odds, he became
(B) having had no formal medical training, in struggling against overwhelming odds to become
(C) who, having no formal medical training, he struggled against overwhelming odds in becoming
(D) who, having had no formal medical training and struggled against overwhelming odds, became
(E) who had no formal medical training, struggled against overwhelming odds to become  

答案是E.    

D与E该如何理解？？ 我总觉得E中 to become 是错的，不定式用在这里不是表达目的性的吗？感觉不符合句子的意思！

yangli317

有个定律可以死记，就是having done做定语修饰名词必错的。
我觉得to become在这里表示他struggle的目的，我的理解是他奋斗就为了变成...

cyang16

有个定律可以死记，就是having done做定语修饰名词必错的。
我觉得to become在这里表示他struggle的目的，我的理解是他奋斗就为了变成...

-- by 会员 yangli317 (2009/11/25 0:00:38)

但是不觉得做prep的题，有些题总是打破常规。having done 已经在好几题都是正确。就如同being 也有正确的时候。总觉的死记还是不行，还是要理解！

cyang16

有个定律可以死记，就是having done做定语修饰名词必错的。
我觉得to become在这里表示他struggle的目的，我的理解是他奋斗就为了变成...

-- by 会员 yangli317 (2009/11/25 0:00:38)

而且句中说他没有接受过正规的培训却成为一名医生，应该是没有没接受过正规培训是为了当医生的意思在里面吧~~总觉得to become在这里有问题

jiafei加

我觉得这道题目应该从逻辑意思上面理解。这道题的强调重点是他在努力奋斗成为···，D已经改变了原文的重点，并且改的句子很不顺口