求助关于比较的问题

cathyhu1995

In addition to having more protein -than wheat does, the protein in rice is higher quality than that in wheat, with more of the amino acids essential to the human diet.

• Athe protein in rice is higher quality than that in
• Brice has protein of higher quality than that in
• Cthe protein in rice is higher in quality than it is in
• Drice protein is higher in quality than it is in
• Erice has a protein higher in quality than
• OA ：B
• 做题思路是：In addition to having more protein -than wheat does 这边缺少主语，所以我认为rice比起 the protein in rice 更好,如果没有前面半句话，答案感觉都可以
• 我想问的是如果不看前半句，单纯只看后面的比较，that 可否，it可否 。因为我记得以前在og上面做过的题目，也是比较，好像是两个不同时段的价格，than后面出现了价格但是就是错的，好像是因为前后的价格不是一个价格所以it同类不同物，所以要删除，有小伙伴可否详细解释一下呢。还有就是关于E，我能理解这边会有起义因为更好的答案是rice has a protein higher in quality than wheat has，如果题目变成 the protein in rice is higher in quality than in wheat是否可以呢  。
• 感谢，因为最近做了太多题目了，感觉脑子混了。
• According to recent studies comparing the nutritional value of meat from wild animals and meat from domesticated animals, wild animals have less total fat than do livestock fed on grain and more of a kind of fat they think is good for cardiac health.
  
  
  A.    wild animals have less total fat than do livestock fed on grain and more of a kind of fat they think is
  B.    wild animals have less total fat than livestock（ fed on grain） and more of a kind of fat thought to be
  C.    wild animals have less total fat than that of livestock fed on grain and have more fat of a kind thought to be
  D.    total fat of wild animals is less than livestock fed on grain and they have more fat of a kind thought to be
  E.    total fat is less in wild animals than tha of livestock fed on grain and more of their fat is of a kind they think
• 同样还有这道题答案是B, 我觉得B 是best answer，但是C 我的问题在于 如果前面是所有格，或者是a of b 的结构，在than 后面做比较的时候是不是that of 。。。。这样才算平行。
• 谢谢大家
• 
  

HoganTong

GMAT不建议对题目做引申思考，虽然引申思考是一个很好的学习习惯，但不太适用于GMAT。因为GMAT的SC并没有绝对不可打破的语法规则，语法规则经常需要为语义让步（尤其在高分段的题目更是如此），所以对某一道题去举一反三可能会跑偏，即使你总结出了正确的语法，换道题也不一定用得上了。

先说第一题，E错误的原因是将protein和wheat做比较，不合逻辑。你的举一反三是对的，但是注意题干前半句in addition to的对象是rice，所以主语一定是rice而不是protein。

再看第二题，C的错误除了不平行（which is more of a grammar mistake），还有一个原因是C的这种表述没有抓到语义的实质。不是说野生动物的脂肪总量比家养牲口少，而是野生动物比家养动物的脂肪少，C选项这种表述说的是前一种，但我们要的语义是后一种。虽然即便按C选项我们也明白作者想表达的意思，但GMAT的SC考察的恰恰就是你把一句能看明白语义但写的不太规范的句子捋顺了重新说一遍的能力。

firexxfire

HoganTong 发表于 2019-4-15 16:06
GMAT不建议对题目做引申思考，虽然引申思考是一个很好的学习习惯，但不太适用于GMAT。因为GMAT的SC并没有绝 ...

同意！