具体是哪里的没标记但是错题里有这道题希望有人可以解答一下

sunyuwei

To meet the rising marketing demand for fish and seafood, suppliers are growing fish twice as fast as their natural growth rate, cutting their feed allotment by nearly half and raising them on special diets.

A. their natural growth rate, cutting their feed allotment

B. their natural growth rate, their feed allotment cut

C. growing them naturally, cutting their feed allotment

D. they grow naturally, cutting their feed allotment

E. they grow naturally, with their feed allotment cut

对于这道题中关于A do B as fast as C do D 的平行问题有点疑问，这个比较形式的短语是固定的吗？C我认为是逻辑问题因为养鱼不可能说自然的养殖，自然和人工养殖本来就是抵触的。但是解释里面说前后不平行，suppliers are doing ..as fast as doing，不认为有什么不对称反而我认为比较D，they的指代会有歧义。望解答 谢谢

sunyuwei

再来一次！！

sunyuwei

有没有人对平行这个点再讲一下看法撒~

sunyuwei

还有指教的亲么~

sunyuwei

yatina 发表于 2014-11-28 20:33
一般来说，A句代表出题人的意图。
A选项“their natural growth rate”，说的是fish的自然生长速度；
C选项 ...

我同意你说的逻辑问题 就是对于这部分我觉得疑惑。解释当中说C as fast as前后不平行 觉得有问题~

yatina

一般来说，A句代表出题人的意图。
A选项“their natural growth rate”，说的是fish的自然生长速度；
C选项“growing them naturally”变成了人养fish，改变原意；
D选项“they grow naturally”说的不就是fish自然生长么，所以D

sunyuwei

yatina 发表于 2014-11-28 20:10
楼主能给出标准答案吗？Q2和Q3能不能再详细描述下，没看懂？

Q1.对于这道题中关于A do B as fast as C do  ...

答案是D，我的意思是说我认为suppliers are doing.. as fast as doing... 这个平行的形式很完整。为什么一定要在as fast as 前后引出两句话，虽然这样也是平行的但是我觉得反而会使they产生指代的歧义。谢谢==

yatina

楼主能给出标准答案吗？Q2和Q3能不能再详细描述下，没看懂？

Q1.对于这道题中关于A do B as fast as C do D 的平行问题有点疑问，这个比较形式的短语是固定的吗？
     我认为答案的意思是说as fast as比较前后的形式要平行。

sunyuwei

顶顶顶顶顶。。