急求教曼哈顿CH13关于动名词前面的名词必须为所有格形式但后一个例句有矛盾~~

lionsue

摘抄：
A noun preceding a gerund must be in the possessive case if the noun is the doer of the action described by the gerund.

Wrong: Mike SWIMMING is the product of new coaching techniques.

Right: Mike's SWIMMING is the product of new coaching techniques.
Mike himself might be the product of new coaching techniques in some way, but if you want to talk about his behavior, you must say Mike's swimming, nor Mike swimming.

Before applying this rule, make sure that the -ing form does indeed function as a noun rather than as a noun modifier. Sometimes either interpretation may be possible.

Suspect: I like Mike SWIMMING. (=I like Mike only as he swims, noc as he runs?
OR I like for him to be swimming rather than lifting weights?)

Right: I like Mike's SWIMMING. (= I like his swimming itself.)

Right: Mike SWIMMING is a sight to behold. (Mike himself can be the sight.)

Right: Mike's SWIMMING is a sight to behold. (The swimming can be the sight.)

问题：既然说了动名词前面名词须为所有格形式为什么倒数第二个例句中是MIKE swimming但却是正确的呢？

cuteyaoyao

sisichen666 发表于 2013-1-7 19:44
亲看一下，你自己说的：but if you want to talk about his behavior, you must say Mike's swimming, nor  ...

谢谢sisi 秒懂！！！！

DUKB24

DD哥yo，，，，，还能上来遛一遛yo。。。O(∩_∩)O~忙了吧

-- by 会员 sisichen666 (2013/1/8 1:11:27)

还剩最后两科final就能解放了哈

sisichen666

DD哥yo，，，，，还能上来遛一遛yo。。。O(∩_∩)O~忙了吧

DUKB24

亲看一下，你自己说的：but if you want to talk about his behavior, you must say Mike's swimming, nor Mike swimming. 强调behavior时才会用到‘s swimming。
这句话已经在后面说明了强调的是mike本身，所以是Right: Mike SWIMMING is a sight to behold. (Mike himself can be the sight.)

-- by 会员 sisichen666 (2013/1/7 19:44:32)

倒数第二个是强调MIKE


倒数第一个是强调swimming


注意区分核心词


sisi好久不见了

sisichen666

亲看一下，你自己说的：but if you want to talk about his behavior, you must say Mike's swimming, nor Mike swimming. 强调behavior时才会用到‘s swimming。
这句话已经在后面说明了强调的是mike本身，所以是Right: Mike SWIMMING is a sight to behold. (Mike himself can be the sight.)