l老题目在线求问 OG SC43

wellsli

43.Laos has a land area about the same as Great Britain but only four million in population, where many are members of hill tribes ensconced in the virtually inaccessible mountain valleys of the north.(A)    about the same as Great Britain but only four million in population, where many
(B)    of about the same size as Great Britain is, but in Laos there is a population of only four million, and many
(C)    that is about the same size as Great Britain's land area, but in Laos with a population of only four million people, many of them
(D)    comparable to the size of Great Britain, but only four million in population, and many
(E)    comparable to that of Great Britain but a population of only four million people, many of whom
OA: E
问一下D项比较 area comparable to the size有没有比较对象的不一致，总感觉area不能和size比较啊？明明E项 that（area的new copy更好）。但是也有NN说这里的比较是对的，求一个解释呀~
然后哪位NN能帮忙贴一个many of them many of whom的详细比较转帖  

sbyangyi

关于第一个问题同意你，area 和 size不能比较.. 这里比较的是land area ，not size


第二个问题：
摘自我总结的excel：


some of them 和some of which所传达的意思也有所不同（OG12 #100也有同样的用法）：


SOME OF WHICH and SOME OF THEM serve different purposes.


SOME OF WHICH serves to modify a NOUN and requires its own verb:
The stars, SOME OF WHICH travel at tremendous speeds, are always in motion.


The modifying clause here (some of which travel at tremendous speeds) tells us more about the STARS themselves.


SOME OF THEM serves to modify a CLAUSE and is NOT provided its own verb:


The stars are always in motion, SOME OF THEM at tremendous speeds.
Here, the modifying phrase (some of them at tremendous speeds) tells us more not about the stars themselves but about HOW the stars are ALWAYS IN MOTION (they are in motion AT TREMENDOUS SPEEDS).

-- by 会员 DUKB24 (2012/9/1 20:52:20)

您好，问道，我看曼哈顿第四版里有个this model explians all known particles,Some of them only recently divorced.这里的divorced是作adj表示离婚的么？这里的some指代什么呢？

wellsli

关于第一个问题同意你，area 和 size不能比较.. 这里比较的是land area ，not size


第二个问题：
摘自我总结的excel：


some of them 和some of which所传达的意思也有所不同（OG12 #100也有同样的用法）：


SOME OF WHICH and SOME OF THEM serve different purposes.


SOME OF WHICH serves to modify a NOUN and requires its own verb:
The stars, SOME OF WHICH travel at tremendous speeds, are always in motion.


The modifying clause here (some of which travel at tremendous speeds) tells us more about the STARS themselves.


SOME OF THEM serves to modify a CLAUSE and is NOT provided its own verb:


The stars are always in motion, SOME OF THEM at tremendous speeds.
Here, the modifying phrase (some of them at tremendous speeds) tells us more not about the stars themselves but about HOW the stars are ALWAYS IN MOTION (they are in motion AT TREMENDOUS SPEEDS).

-- by 会员 DUKB24 (2012/9/1 20:52:20)

感谢NN回复~ 我会仔细研究~

DUKB24

关于第一个问题同意你，area 和 size不能比较.. 这里比较的是land area ，not size


第二个问题：
摘自我总结的excel：


some of them 和some of which所传达的意思也有所不同（OG12 #100也有同样的用法）：


SOME OF WHICH and SOME OF THEM serve different purposes.


SOME OF WHICH serves to modify a NOUN and requires its own verb:
The stars, SOME OF WHICH travel at tremendous speeds, are always in motion.


The modifying clause here (some of which travel at tremendous speeds) tells us more about the STARS themselves.


SOME OF THEM serves to modify a CLAUSE and is NOT provided its own verb:


The stars are always in motion, SOME OF THEM at tremendous speeds.
Here, the modifying phrase (some of them at tremendous speeds) tells us more not about the stars themselves but about HOW the stars are ALWAYS IN MOTION (they are in motion AT TREMENDOUS SPEEDS).

wellsli

有没有NN解答一下...

wellsli

up