求商科Phd定位

hunteruibe

请各位帮忙一位朋友定位，对商科PHD研究感兴趣，因为是女生想将来留在学校：

本科 对外经贸 法律，成绩81%；
研究生 牛津大学 法律与金融，Merit；
在中央部委法律工作3年，国际组织2年，大券商风险管理1年，现在内资律所。


GMAT 700+，研究经历只有学校的dissertaion...，发过1篇国内国际性论坛法律类论文。有数学和微观经济学基础，请问可以申请什么层次的学校，什么样的专业适合？


非常感谢啦~~~~~~

纳寻寻

楼主的问题是，你要读金融或是经济PHD。 你的数学可能是不够的。 单单只是大学的一些微积分加上线代加概率论那些是不够的。  你最好要学下 ordinary differential equation +real analysis 最好也要学下partial differential equation 和stochastic calculus

-- by 会员 miltoning (2012/8/20 9:07:04)

你好，我现在在美国读金融的硕士，也是想申请fin或者Econ的phd，正纠结于数学课程的准备。想请教一下，你说的这些课是为了利于申请时被录取还是更倾向于为读phd做research时候的准备呢？谢谢啦。

hunteruibe

有点小歪 。。。

lewnysh

讨论歪楼了么

hunteruibe

Economics是对数学要求高，她应该没想过。。。感谢几位的意见哈~~~

还是 ACC相关的或者商学院对数学要求不高，哪位大侠有具体的建议不？

lingxiaosusu

。。。"自作多情" 了。。。

lingxiaosusu

金融和econ的要求本来就不一样
学校网站上的说法很多时候只是一种signal和良好的期望哈哈

两位top school的博士生和发考题就不要争了，好好玩儿，莫打架

-- by 会员 judydongxueni (2012/8/21 9:01:36)

miltoning

I am probably very stupid regarding to this, but I do not think those courses or backgound knowledge you listed are that necessary. I have many classmates who did BBA in their undergrad study (in US) and their math knowledge were very limited (only restricted to those core math courses in b-school), but they still got admitted by top PhD finance programs in the US and they all survicved for MORE THAN 2 years so far.

Maybe they are super smart, so they do not need to take those courses. But personally i do not think those courses are that important. If I am wrong, I apoloize.


ion 和stochastic calculus

-- by 会员 miltoning (2012/8/20 9:07:04)

别误导人，finance和econ得phd里面不懂你说得这些得人绝对比懂你说得这些得人多。

-- by 会员 Zingales (2012/8/20 13:53:11)

你才在那儿误导人。知道什么啊， 你。  我在美国读了2年PHD了，难道我不清楚？

-- by 会员 miltoning (2012/8/21 2:29:20)

小鬼，我当faculty得时间都比你读phd得时间长了。。。

-- by 会员 Zingales (2012/8/21 3:57:41)

[/quote]

你可能在国内做faculty.而且教的不是econ或是finance.  我说的那几门课你应该知道的，TOP的学校有几个不要求这几门课的呢？

-- by 会员 miltoning (2012/8/21 6:58:02)

[/quote]

-- by 会员 lingxiaosusu (2012/8/21 7:14:13)

[/quote]

Cornell. Econ PHD对于数学的说明。 “ There is a strong admissions and financial aid bias towards students with more mathematics: differential equations, real analysis, mathematical probability and statistics, optimization, topology, and stocastic differential equations, among many others.”  http://economics.cornell.edu/graduate/phdprereqs.html。


Upenn（ Wharton) Applied Econ的PHD对于数学的说明。 We require (1) at least two courses in calculus, (2) linear algebra, (3) differential equations, and (4) probability and statistics. We also recommended that you have taken: (1) real analysis, (2) econometrics, (3) stochastic calculus.  http://www.wharton.upenn.edu/doctoral/programs/applied-economics-faq.cfm


NYU的Econ 对于数学的说明。 You should definitely have taken single-variable and multivariate calculus. It is expected that you would have a background in linear algebra, and an exposure to probability and statistics. Many of our applicants also have a background in difference or differential equations, and they have been exposed to rigorous thinking in limits, continuity, and basic topological concepts (openness, compactness, etc.). There are a good number of applicants who have more than this: e.g., some measure theory and exposure to rigorous probability theory and stochastic processes.  http://econ.as.nyu.edu/object/econ.faq.doc


U Maryland Econ PHD 的说明 “It is extremely rare for us to admit a student who has not completed the equivalent of three semesters of calculus, a semester of linear algebra, and a semester in differential equations at the time of application. The overwhelming majority of admitted students have also completed course work in real analysis or other upper-level mathematics courses.”  http://www.econ.umd.edu/graduate/prospective/faq1

还有很多，我不列举了。 你如果说只是读个很一般的学校的话，数学没那些课还是有机会。想申TOP的。 别人也说的很清楚了

-- by 会员 miltoning (2012/8/21 8:09:39)

[/quote]

很不幸，你说的这四个学校里面的econ phd，我认识三个学校的，有的学校还不止一个，但是没有一个人的background符合他们list出来的这些要求的。

-- by 会员 Zingales (2012/8/21 8:33:24)

[/quote]你怎么说都可以，也没人可以验证你说的话。我可以说我认识10个以上这几个学校的都有相关背景，谁能验证呢。 所以还是上面贴出来的信息可信，最少是官方的一个声明，相对于你说的认识谁谁要可信的多

Zingales

I am probably very stupid regarding to this, but I do not think those courses or backgound knowledge you listed are that necessary. I have many classmates who did BBA in their undergrad study (in US) and their math knowledge were very limited (only restricted to those core math courses in b-school), but they still got admitted by top PhD finance programs in the US and they all survicved for MORE THAN 2 years so far.

Maybe they are super smart, so they do not need to take those courses. But personally i do not think those courses are that important. If I am wrong, I apoloize.


ion 和stochastic calculus

-- by 会员 miltoning (2012/8/20 9:07:04)

别误导人，finance和econ得phd里面不懂你说得这些得人绝对比懂你说得这些得人多。

-- by 会员 Zingales (2012/8/20 13:53:11)

你才在那儿误导人。知道什么啊， 你。  我在美国读了2年PHD了，难道我不清楚？

-- by 会员 miltoning (2012/8/21 2:29:20)

[/quote]


小鬼，我当faculty得时间都比你读phd得时间长了。。。

-- by 会员 Zingales (2012/8/21 3:57:41)

[/quote]

你可能在国内做faculty.而且教的不是econ或是finance.  我说的那几门课你应该知道的，TOP的学校有几个不要求这几门课的呢？

-- by 会员 miltoning (2012/8/21 6:58:02)

[/quote]

-- by 会员 lingxiaosusu (2012/8/21 7:14:13)

[/quote]

Cornell. Econ PHD对于数学的说明。 “ There is a strong admissions and financial aid bias towards students with more mathematics: differential equations, real analysis, mathematical probability and statistics, optimization, topology, and stocastic differential equations, among many others.”  http://economics.cornell.edu/graduate/phdprereqs.html。


Upenn（ Wharton) Applied Econ的PHD对于数学的说明。 We require (1) at least two courses in calculus, (2) linear algebra, (3) differential equations, and (4) probability and statistics. We also recommended that you have taken: (1) real analysis, (2) econometrics, (3) stochastic calculus.  http://www.wharton.upenn.edu/doctoral/programs/applied-economics-faq.cfm


NYU的Econ 对于数学的说明。 You should definitely have taken single-variable and multivariate calculus. It is expected that you would have a background in linear algebra, and an exposure to probability and statistics. Many of our applicants also have a background in difference or differential equations, and they have been exposed to rigorous thinking in limits, continuity, and basic topological concepts (openness, compactness, etc.). There are a good number of applicants who have more than this: e.g., some measure theory and exposure to rigorous probability theory and stochastic processes.  http://econ.as.nyu.edu/object/econ.faq.doc


U Maryland Econ PHD 的说明 “It is extremely rare for us to admit a student who has not completed the equivalent of three semesters of calculus, a semester of linear algebra, and a semester in differential equations at the time of application. The overwhelming majority of admitted students have also completed course work in real analysis or other upper-level mathematics courses.”  http://www.econ.umd.edu/graduate/prospective/faq1

还有很多，我不列举了。 你如果说只是读个很一般的学校的话，数学没那些课还是有机会。想申TOP的。 别人也说的很清楚了

-- by 会员 miltoning (2012/8/21 8:09:39)

[/quote]

很不幸，你说的这四个学校里面的econ phd，我认识三个学校的，有的学校还不止一个，但是没有一个人的background符合他们list出来的这些要求的。

miltoning

I am probably very stupid regarding to this, but I do not think those courses or backgound knowledge you listed are that necessary. I have many classmates who did BBA in their undergrad study (in US) and their math knowledge were very limited (only restricted to those core math courses in b-school), but they still got admitted by top PhD finance programs in the US and they all survicved for MORE THAN 2 years so far.

Maybe they are super smart, so they do not need to take those courses. But personally i do not think those courses are that important. If I am wrong, I apoloize.


ion 和stochastic calculus

-- by 会员 miltoning (2012/8/20 9:07:04)

别误导人，finance和econ得phd里面不懂你说得这些得人绝对比懂你说得这些得人多。

-- by 会员 Zingales (2012/8/20 13:53:11)

[/quote]

你才在那儿误导人。知道什么啊， 你。  我在美国读了2年PHD了，难道我不清楚？

-- by 会员 miltoning (2012/8/21 2:29:20)

[/quote]


小鬼，我当faculty得时间都比你读phd得时间长了。。。

-- by 会员 Zingales (2012/8/21 3:57:41)

[/quote]

你可能在国内做faculty.而且教的不是econ或是finance.  我说的那几门课你应该知道的，TOP的学校有几个不要求这几门课的呢？

-- by 会员 miltoning (2012/8/21 6:58:02)

[/quote]

-- by 会员 lingxiaosusu (2012/8/21 7:14:13)

[/quote]

Cornell. Econ PHD对于数学的说明。 “ There is a strong admissions and financial aid bias towards students with more mathematics: differential equations, real analysis, mathematical probability and statistics, optimization, topology, and stocastic differential equations, among many others.”  http://economics.cornell.edu/graduate/phdprereqs.html。


Upenn（ Wharton) Applied Econ的PHD对于数学的说明。 We require (1) at least two courses in calculus, (2) linear algebra, (3) differential equations, and (4) probability and statistics. We also recommended that you have taken: (1) real analysis, (2) econometrics, (3) stochastic calculus.  http://www.wharton.upenn.edu/doctoral/programs/applied-economics-faq.cfm


NYU的Econ 对于数学的说明。 You should definitely have taken single-variable and multivariate calculus. It is expected that you would have a background in linear algebra, and an exposure to probability and statistics. Many of our applicants also have a background in difference or differential equations, and they have been exposed to rigorous thinking in limits, continuity, and basic topological concepts (openness, compactness, etc.). There are a good number of applicants who have more than this: e.g., some measure theory and exposure to rigorous probability theory and stochastic processes.  http://econ.as.nyu.edu/object/econ.faq.doc


U Maryland Econ PHD 的说明 “It is extremely rare for us to admit a student who has not completed the equivalent of three semesters of calculus, a semester of linear algebra, and a semester in differential equations at the time of application. The overwhelming majority of admitted students have also completed course work in real analysis or other upper-level mathematics courses.”  http://www.econ.umd.edu/graduate/prospective/faq1

还有很多，我不列举了。 你如果说只是读个很一般的学校的话，数学没那些课还是有机会。想申TOP的。 别人也说的很清楚了

lingxiaosusu

I am probably very stupid regarding to this, but I do not think those courses or backgound knowledge you listed are that necessary. I have many classmates who did BBA in their undergrad study (in US) and their math knowledge were very limited (only restricted to those core math courses in b-school), but they still got admitted by top PhD finance programs in the US and they all survicved for MORE THAN 2 years so far.

Maybe they are super smart, so they do not need to take those courses. But personally i do not think those courses are that important. If I am wrong, I apoloize.


ion 和stochastic calculus

-- by 会员 miltoning (2012/8/20 9:07:04)

[/quote]



别误导人，finance和econ得phd里面不懂你说得这些得人绝对比懂你说得这些得人多。

-- by 会员 Zingales (2012/8/20 13:53:11)

[/quote]

你才在那儿误导人。知道什么啊， 你。  我在美国读了2年PHD了，难道我不清楚？

-- by 会员 miltoning (2012/8/21 2:29:20)

[/quote]


小鬼，我当faculty得时间都比你读phd得时间长了。。。

-- by 会员 Zingales (2012/8/21 3:57:41)

[/quote]

你可能在国内做faculty.而且教的不是econ或是finance.  我说的那几门课你应该知道的，TOP的学校有几个不要求这几门课的呢？

-- by 会员 miltoning (2012/8/21 6:58:02)

[/quote]