prep2008 179 对称问题

有理想没有钱

UnlikeGeorge in 1968 and John Anderson in 1980, both of whom running asindependent candidates, H. Ross Perot's independent run for the presidencyin 1992 arose not from an unsuccessful effort to gain a major party nominationbut from a desire to establish a viable third party in American politics.
A.George in 1968 and John Anderson in 1980, both of whom running asindependent candidates,
B.George in 1968 and John Anderson in 1980, each of whom ran asindependent candidates,
C.George in 1968 and John Anderson in 1980, both of which ran as anindependent candidate,
D.the independent candidates, George in 1968 and John Anderson in 1980,
E.the independent candidacies of George in 1968 and John Anderson in1980,
我选的D，但是答案E，我没觉得D哪里错，而且D直接说INDEPENDENT CANDIDATES, 和后面的H. Ross Perot's independent run for the presidency对应，这样不是更直接的对比，相比于E来说，我有点不明白，请好心人帮忙回答下，谢谢

caiqiangjie

IMO，比较的是事，不是人，H. Ross Perot's independent run for the presidency可知

caiqiangjie

IMO，比较的是事，不是人，H. Ross Perot's independent run可知

teddybearj4

unlike前后比较的是HRP时期的无党派者，和GW、JA的无党派者。

如果是D的话句子的逻辑意思就不对了，更像是HRP的无党派者和无党派者GW、无党派者JA比较了，而GW、AJ变成了同位语修饰无党派者，而不是像E一样无党派者的限定性的modifier。

UnlikeGeorge in 1968 and John Anderson in 1980, both of whom running asindependent candidates, H. Ross Perot's independent run for the presidencyin 1992 arose not from an unsuccessful effort to gain a major party nominationbut from a desire to establish a viable third party in American politics.
A.George in 1968 and John Anderson in 1980, both of whom running asindependent candidates,
B.George in 1968 and John Anderson in 1980, each of whom ran asindependent candidates,
C.George in 1968 and John Anderson in 1980, both of which ran as anindependent candidate,
D.the independent candidates, George in 1968 and John Anderson in 1980,
E.the independent candidacies of George in 1968 and John Anderson in1980,
我选的D，但是答案E，我没觉得D哪里错，而且D直接说INDEPENDENT CANDIDATES, 和后面的H. Ross Perot's independent run for the presidency对应，这样不是更直接的对比，相比于E来说，我有点不明白，请好心人帮忙回答下，谢谢

-- by 会员 有理想没有钱 (2012/2/16 12:51:52)