问一道语法JJ题

chu9qlwy

Half of the nearly 8million people that identified themselves to be P.S live within the U.S.
A the nearly 8 millionpeople that identified themselves to be P.S., live within
B the nearly 8 millionpeople, identifying themselves as P.S., live in
C nearly 8 million people,identifying themselves as P.S., live in
D nearly 8 million peoplewho identified themselves to be P.S. live in
E nearly 8 million peoplewho identified themselves as P.S., live in

九珍豆腐

好了，看过PREP08了，主动上来更正错误。这个identifying前后都有逗号，肯定错。那就E吧，没得选了。

-- by 会员 high1cn (2011/10/11 11:04:14)

为什么都有逗号就错呢，前边没有逗号是因为怕和后边有修饰的歧义，没有逗号相当于限定向前修饰，但现在后边是动词，就不会存在歧义了。而且E中修饰用的是一般过去时态，和主句时态不一致

ethanli

我觉得选A啊

high1cn

好了，看过PREP08了，主动上来更正错误。这个identifying前后都有逗号，肯定错。那就E吧，没得选了。

high1cn

同问，倾向B，identify as; people 指特定的那群“identify themselves"的人，而不是整个US的人，我觉得应该有the；此句没有分词形式混淆定于状语的可能性，所以没必要用从句，identifying就可以了。请指教。