无比费解的一道题目

ashleyqiuqiu

In Hungary, as in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many of which are in middle management and light industry.
A. as in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many of which are in
B. as with much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women works, many in
C. as in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many of them in
D. like much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women works, and many are
E. like much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many are in
这道题居然给我答案是c。。。太让我费解了。。。求大牛详详细细的指教。。。

henrywang916

Nate00000 发表于 2011-5-14 21:02
不对吧，2楼说的。。。As + noun. 表示作为。。。原文的意思应该是比较，只有D和E符合。D没有谓语，我选 ...

非常好，解答了我的疑问，好人一生平安！

cuson

楼上讲的真好，像一个叫rajor的老师

huangyouhuifei

<1>A选项-->which不能指代人，把which改成whom就对了。
<2>D/E比较对象不可比。
<3>主句是an overwhelming proportion of women work，有了主语an overwhelming proportion of women和动词work，这个句子已经完整，后面的内容是修饰women的。
Analogy：
I have 30 classmates, many of them from Japan.-->correct
I have 30 classmates, many of whom come from Japan.-->correct
I have 30 classmates, many of them come from Japan.-->incorrect and run-on
Last night I ate 10 apples, many of them imported from Veitnam.-->correct
Last night I ate 10 apples, many of which were imported from Veitnam.-->correct
Last night I ate 10 apples, many of them were imported from Veitnam.-->incorrect and run-on
不用去纠缠这个术语上叫什么独立主格呀或者什么的，因为这不重要，反而阻碍语法学习的效率和速度。
<4>as之后可以跟句子，也可以跟介词短语，此题属于介词短语，而且C选项很平行。
<5>an overwhelming proportion of women是复数，因为women是复数。一般来说X of Y的单复数根据X来定，但此处是特例，根据Y来定。比例呀、百分之几呀什么的都是根据Y来定单复数。
比如：
a great percentage of rain is...
a great percentage of books are...
two-fifth of all the water is...
two-fifth of all the cars are...
an overwhelming proportion of energy is...
an overwhelming proportion of women are...

Nate00000

不对吧，2楼说的。。。

As + noun. 表示作为。。。原文的意思应该是比较，只有D和E符合。D没有谓语，我选E.

-- by 会员 chasingM7 (2011/3/7 16:44:27)

+1

熊你妹

句子的主干是an overwhelming proporation of women work  
an overwhelming proporation of women 是主语 work是谓语
many of them是独立主格结构，修饰前面的women , 这些women in middle management and light industry。

可能不能用many of which 的原因是 which指代的是an overwhelming proporation，但是proporation不能in middle management。？这个不是很懂！

yarndyed

不对吧，2楼说的。。。

As + noun. 表示作为。。。原文的意思应该是比较，只有D和E符合。D没有谓语，我选E.

===========
此处不是比较HUNGARY 和欧洲其他国家。IN HUNGARY是个状语。如果把IN去掉的话我觉得是可以用LIKE的，但是去掉IN的话HUNGARY和欧洲的其他国家都需要做主语了，作为动作的发出者。

yarndyed

你确定题是对的吗？in hungary, as in much of eastern europe, an overwhelming proporation of women woif, many of them in middle management and light industry.这根本不是一个句子，哪有谓语啊。。。请教～～

=========

谓语是WORK啊 （ 你打成WOIF了）

vvbao

这句里面as没问题啊，和OG82题一个类型的嘛

chasingM7

不对吧，2楼说的。。。

As + noun. 表示作为。。。原文的意思应该是比较，只有D和E符合。D没有谓语，我选E.