一道PP题，定语从句讨论

piacia

148. (32773-!-item-!-188;#058&006296)

In contrast to some fish eggsrequiring months to incubate, the Rio Grande silvery minnow produces eggsthat hatch in about 24 hours, yielding larvae that can swim in just three tofour days.

(A) some fish eggs requiring monthsto incubate

(B) some fish, whose eggs requiremonths to incubate

(C) some fish that have eggsrequiring months to incubate

(D) the requirement of months ofincubation for some fish eggs

(E) requiring months of incubation,as some fish eggs do

B，C主要区别是什么。。我觉得都可以，为什么答案是B，笔记里只说that have eggs的表达不准确，求指教

viviansecret

B比C的表达更简洁有效。

piacia

楼上的解释应该是B和C所强调的方面不同。。。对吧。。这么解释倒是很有道理

mudiduange

some fish that have eggs requiring months to incubate

表达不准确，这个解释是正确的，只是笼统了点

你仔细看这个句子的意思，其实前后相比的是两种鱼卵的孵化时间，C选项前面讲的是这种鱼有eggs, 后面则讲的是其eggs只要24小时就能孵化，逻辑上不对。

Lacus

用了have，表示动作发生有先后的对比，但本句话交代了两个事实，其间并没有关于时间的比较，所以B>C。