Manhattan SC review上的一道题

gaor

Tense部分的一道例题，但没找到标准答案

When he phones her, she tells him to stop calling, but he acted as if he had not understood her.
a) she tells him to stop calling, but he acted as if he had not understood her.
b) she told him to stop calling, but he acted as if he had not understood her.
c) she tells him to stop calling, but he acts as if he did not understood her.
d) she tells him to stop calling, but he acts as if he has not understood her.
e) she tells him to stop calling, but he acted as if he does not understand her.

这道题哪个选项对呢？多谢

fannybeibei

答案是D么？
。。。。。。。。。可as if后面难道不该是虚拟么？

gaor

多谢，我在A跟D之间纠结，感觉D应该是正确的

A. she tells him to stop calling, but he acted as if he had not understood her
B. she told him to stop calling, but he acted as if he had not understood her
C. she tells him to stop calling, but he acted as if he did not understood her
D. she tells him to stop calling, but he acted as if he has not understood her
E. she tells him to stop calling, but he acted as if he does not understood her

多谢

bdsjb116

不是很理解为什么要排除完成时，虽然完成时看起来没有一般过去时要“保险”，但毕竟表现出2个动作的先后顺序

When he phones her，she tells him to stop calling, but he acts as if he has not understood her.
当他打电话给她的时候，她让他不要再打了，但他表现出（当时）他并没有理解她（的话）.

看OG里面先排除完成时的题都是因为选项中的一般过去时不存在明显语法错误。但这题里面C有明显的错误，相比起来D的时态错误就轻微的多。所以我选D

gaor

我一开始也认为选C，但后来觉得C有问题，'he did not understood her'
应该是 did not understand 才对

绯雨白梅香

C吧？个人觉得是C。可以排除所有用完成时态的，因为没有使用完成时态的提示词。
排除A.B.D，
然后剩下C.E
“but”前后动词时态应一致。