求助，第十版OG第一题（征求从完成时的角度的讲解）

alicejingli

1.The Wallerstein study indicates that even after a decade young men and women still experience some of the effects of a divorce occurring when a child.

(A)occurring when a child

(B)occurring when children

(C)that occurred when a child

(D)that occurred when they were children

(E)that has occurred as each was a child
，我就不明白E的完成时，错在那里了，因为他们（young men and women）小时候父母离婚，对现在来说不就是有影响，所以为何E的完成时不对？

alicejingli

1.The Wallerstein study indicates that even after a decade young men and women still experience some of the effects of a divorce occurring when a child.

(A)occurring when a child

(B)occurring when children

(C)that occurred when a child

(D)that occurred when they were children

(E)that has occurred as each was a child
，我就不明白E的完成时，错在那里了，因为他们（young men and women）小时候父母离婚，对现在来说不就是有影响，所以为何E的完成时不对？

-- by 会员 alicejingli (2010/8/11 21:18:44)

这道题，我还是顺不过来E选项的完成时为啥不对。。。有没有人能在给我讲讲。因为从意思上看就是说年轻人仍然被离婚（幼年时期的离婚）影响。所以，完成时的意思不就是对现在依然有影响吗？

希望有人能从完成时角度讲讲。谢谢

花子落落

只看从句ok？
A divorce occurred when they were children。多么完美地一句话~
A divorce has occurred as each was a child.  你觉得的呢？

alicejingli

这里动词是occur，是指发生吖~和有没有影响木有关系~~

-- by 会员 花子落落 (2010/8/11 22:02:33)

那可是题目整句话的意思不是再说那些年轻人幼年遭受过父母离婚，这个的确发生在过去，但是对现在有影响，（因为有XX症）所以现在也离婚。
还是说你是怎样判断是否对现在有影响的？是说只依据某个词还是？谢谢你

花子落落

这里动词是occur，是指发生吖~和有没有影响木有关系~~

alicejingli

离婚是过去发生的事情吖~

再是~LZ可以搜以前帖子的~

-- by 会员 花子落落 (2010/8/11 21:35:56)

不是，我觉得离婚是过去发生的但是它对现在已经造成影响了。。。。不明白，急需再讲。谢谢

花子落落

离婚是过去发生的事情吖~

再是~LZ可以搜以前帖子的~