【再问】T-4-Q22

slamshady

Unlike the short flights of the shuttle and earlier spacecraft, which carried sufficient power in fuel cells and batteries, a permanently orbiting space station will have to generate its own electricity.

A.    the short flights of the shuttle and earlier spacecraft, which carried sufficient power in fuel cells and batteries
B.    the shuttle and earlier spacecraft, with sufficient enough power in fuel cells and batteries for their short flights
C.    the short flights of the shuttle and earlier spacecraft, which enabled them to carry sufficient enough power in fuel cells and batteries
D.    the shuttle and earlier spacecraft, which were capable of carrying sufficient power in fuel cells and batteries for their short flights
E.    the flights of the shuttle and earlier spacecraft, whose shortness allowed them to carry sufficient power in fuel cells and batteries

这里之所以选D而不选B，是不是因为B的独立主格无法表明"their“具体指谁，而D用了定语从句使"their"与主句关系更密切，有指代对象？

penelope0823

sofeia 发表于 2010-5-11 12:19
引用：Unlikethe short flights of the shuttle and earlier spacecraft, which carried sufficient power  ...

好棒的解释

ranvolski

sufficiect enough的用法是可以被justify的，但是with的复合结构有问题
。强调某物有某种状态的with结构应该是with sth being xxx 而这里没有了being所以是错的。
另外，unlike放在句首用作副词修饰整个句子，是adjective modifier,而with的复合结构这里的作用也是modifier,形成了夹心modifier，夹心修饰，错。

DUKB24

with + 短语 出现是绝对错误的形式吗？？？   求解答啊~介词加短语不应该是对的么？

-- by 会员 sodalight (2012/10/19 15:42:59)

不是，因为这里会产生歧义，所以被排除了

sodalight

with + 短语 出现是绝对错误的形式吗？？？   求解答啊~介词加短语不应该是对的么？

gudjohnssen

突然觉得，这题B选项的with结构是不是修饰有歧异啊？

Unlike A, with ...., B ....

with结构既可以修饰A，也可以修饰B。所以造成了结构上的不严密。

vampireking

这题别的解释都是牵强，凭什么which就比with好，只要语义正确就行了。
看看Native speaker的解释
two things to add:

(1) sufficient + enough is REDUNDANT.  redundancy is very bad.
same reason you wouldn't say "reply back", "added bonus", or "determined as a result of" (see #138 in OG11, if you have that).

(2) make sure you know that "enough THAT" is incorrect.
the 2 idioms mentioned above are correct.

slamshady

哈哈，没关系，仍然祝福你好运气，好成绩！！！

***********************************************************************

还有一个固定用法 sufficient enough to/for 。。。。指示正确答案的暗示很多。。。-- by 会员 sofeia (2010/5/9 0:42:15

额。。。这不就是说B是对的么？不理解~~~-- by 会员 slamshady (2010/5/9 10:36:19)

哈哈，看来你是应该离开GMAT，放松一下再准备GMAT了。我是说正确的固定搭配应该是---sufficient enough to do sth/for sth  !!!- by 会员 sofeia (2010/5/11 10:37:26)

下个礼拜考了。。。我走不开啦~~~~-- by 会员 slamshady (2010/5/11 13:16:36)

-- by 会员 sofeia (2010/5/11 13:38:16)

[/quote]
The same 2 U ~~~~~~~~

sofeia

哈哈，没关系，仍然祝福你好运气，好成绩！！！

***********************************************************************

还有一个固定用法 sufficient enough to/for 。。。。指示正确答案的暗示很多。。。-- by 会员 sofeia (2010/5/9 0:42:15

额。。。这不就是说B是对的么？不理解~~~-- by 会员 slamshady (2010/5/9 10:36:19)

哈哈，看来你是应该离开GMAT，放松一下再准备GMAT了。我是说正确的固定搭配应该是---sufficient enough to do sth/for sth  !!!- by 会员 sofeia (2010/5/11 10:37:26)

下个礼拜考了。。。我走不开啦~~~~-- by 会员 slamshady (2010/5/11 13:16:36)[/quote]

slamshady

还有一个固定用法 sufficient enough to/for 。。。。指示正确答案的暗示很多。。。

-- by 会员 sofeia (2010/5/9 0:42:15)

额。。。这不就是说B是对的么？不理解~~~

-- by 会员 slamshady (2010/5/9 10:36:19)

哈哈，看来你是应该离开GMAT，放松一下再准备GMAT了。我是说正确的固定搭配应该是---sufficient enough to do sth/for sth  !!!

-- by 会员 sofeia (2010/5/11 10:37:26)

下个礼拜考了。。。我走不开啦~~~~