请教OG18-SC745

victoriaria

原题如下：
Tides typically range from three to six feet, but while some places show no tides at all, some others, such as the Bay of Fundy, have tides of at least thirty feet and more.
(A)  some others, such as the Bay of Fundy, have tides of at least thirty feet and more
(B)  the others, such as the Bay of Fundy, that have tides of more than thirty feet
(C)  others, such as the Bay of Fundy, have tides of more than thirty feet
(D)  those at the Bay of Fundy, which has tides of more than thirty feet
(E)  the ones at the Bay of Fundy have tides of at least thirty feet and more

OA为C，这没问题，我想问的是DE选项OG关于一个spilt的点的解释是：
D The pronoun those, which refers to places , does not make sense along with at the Bay of Fundy, which names a single place
E The word ones, which refers to places, does not make sense along with at the Bay of Fundy, which names a single place
lz看了这道题beatthegmat等一些解释，都没有提到OG这一点，请教OG上这个解释什么意思？并没有get到他在说的点。谢谢~~

victoriaria

fuckoffand 发表于 2018-11-12 15:38
根据句子的意思，应该是对比海浪在某些地方以及在一个地方，即bay of fundy的情况，而d/e的意思是在bay of  ...

好的谢谢~

victoriaria

几许VV 发表于 2018-11-12 15:58
while some places show no tides at all,  those at the Bay of Fundy, which has tides of more than thi ...

解释的很详细，感谢！~

几许VV

while some places show no tides at all,  those at the Bay of Fundy, which has tides of more than thirty feet

前面是 some places，所以后面的those指代的是另一些places，就像

While some letters are written in English, those in the red box are written in Chinese.

所以 those at the Bay of Fundy是错的，因为bay of fundy是一个single place，单一的地点怎么还能有地点在这里呢？

如果句子是这样：while some tides are only one feet ,  those at the Bay of Fundy are more than thirty feet.
那么those at the Bay of Fundy就是正确的用法了。

fuckoffand

根据句子的意思，应该是对比海浪在某些地方以及在一个地方，即bay of fundy的情况，而d/e的意思是在bay of fundy的某一些地方，不符合句子意思，所以out