请教

Hebe0918_0

25. Based on accounts of various ancient writers, scholars have painted a sketchypicture of the activities of an all-female cult that, perhaps as early asthe sixth century B.C., worshipped a goddess known in Latin as Bona Dea, “the good goddess.”

(A) Based onaccounts of various ancient writers,

(B) Basing iton various ancient writers accounts,

(C) Withaccounts of various ancient writers used for a basis,

(D) By theaccounts of various ancient writers they used,

(E) Usingaccounts of various ancient writers,

这道题目为什么不能选A呢？

Hebe0918_0

elusive 发表于 2016-2-18 12:29
A=学者被基于
B=学者基于它，他是什么？
E=学者使用...

这样解释就更清楚了，谢谢

Hebe0918_0

alzn2765 发表于 2016-2-13 12:20
这题主，要考逻，辑主语的问题。
前面这部，分是状，语修饰句中的谓语动词。CD直接歧义scholars用accountso ...

哦， 我理解成scholars based on了，原来应该是a sketchypicture based on， 略搞

alzn2765

这题主，要考逻，辑主语的问题。
前面这部，分是状，语修饰句中的谓语动词。CD直接歧义scholars用accountsofvariousancientwriters来painta sketchypicture是不，可能的，accounts又不是笔或者颜料。
A用了based on表，明主语跟based是动宾关，系而事实上应该是asketchypictures才应该是basedo naccountsofvariousa ncientwriters的。故A错。
B我觉得没啥逻辑错误毕竟整句中只有asketchpicture一个单数名词在主语或者宾语的核心次位置上，但是没有E简单直接。