og 225请教

225. Minnesota is the only one of the contiguous forty-eight states that still has a sizable wolf population. and where this predator remains the archenemy of cattle and sheep.

(A)  that still has a sizable wolf population, and where

(B)  that still has a sizable wolf population, where

(C)  that still has a sizable population of wolves, and where

(D)  where the population of wolves is still sizable;

(E)   where there is still a sizable population of wolves and where

答案E。有人能解释一下D吗？OG的解释 Choice D is grammatically constructed, but it lacks a conjunction that establishes a logical relation between the clauses; since Minnesota as a grammatical subject is separated from the clause following the semicolon, the statement there need not even pertain to Minnesota.我觉得很牵强

and引导的并列结构，定语从句和状语从句的并列存在问题；

我认为这里的两个where都是定语从句。

同意楼上滴

定语从句并列，功能相同

og的意思是说，如果从语法角度讲，是没有问题的，这一点可以从很多og的例子中间看出来，分号后面的内容，在内容上有联系，但是主语可以完全不同，但d语法构造让意思上有缺陷，为什么呢？og解释说，since Minnesota as a grammatical subject is separated from the clause following the semicolon, the statement there need not even pertain to Minnesota.因为Minnesota 被分号一分，已经和后面的半句划清了界限，不做后半句的主语，甚至没有关系了，那你还用 “this” predator， 不知道this在指谁，不着边际呀

一点疑问:我上XDF课时,杨老师特别强调"there be"结构要慎用,一般只能接自然存在的状态,这道题目的E选项似乎不妥啊....

而且,从我做的大部分题目来说,基本选项有there be的都是错误选项.

请各位NN指教!

记住一句saying:

where there is a hope,there is a way.

是这样说的嘛？

然后就记住这个句型了。

回楼上的

Where there is a will, there is a way.