大家来讨论一下这道题

夏雨霏霏 · 发表于 2011-10-1 20:15:54

Are you still reading the other newspaper in town? Did you know that the Daily Bugle is owned by an out-of-town business syndicate that couldn’t care less about the people of Gotham City? Read the Daily Clarion, the only real voice of the people of Gotham City!
Which of the following most directly refutes the argument raised in the advertisement above?
(A) Over half of the advertising revenues of the Daily Clarion come from firms whose headquarters are located outside of Gotham City.
(B) The Daily Clarion usually devotes more of its pages to out-of-town news than does the Daily Bugle.
(C) Nearly 40 percent of the readers of the Daily Clarion reside outside the limits of Gotham City.
(D) The editor-in-chief and all the other members of the editorial staff of the Daily Bugle have lived and worked in Gotham City for ten years or more
(E) The Daily Bugle has been published in Gotham City for a longer time than has the Daily Clarion
选D，但是我觉得B对阿

newstart922 · 发表于 2011-10-2 12:04:43

同问
我觉得D是反驳 out of town business syndicate这个条件的所以正确
但觉得Buedui

夏雨霏霏 · 发表于 2011-10-3 06:33:57

华仔 · 发表于 2011-10-3 10:53:05

题目观点认为由于报纸Daily Bugle的老板易主为Gotham City外的人所以这份报纸对Gotham City人的生活关注度不及报纸Daily Clarion，而题目为问的是哪项为最直接反驳这个观点的。
我认为虽然B项也有很强的反驳力，但D项相比之下就更直接的反驳了。B项只说报纸Daily Clarion用更大的篇幅去报到城外的新闻，但要是Gotham City本来就不大，能发表的有价值的新闻并不多；或者报纸Daily Clarion的页数较多，能报导更多的新闻。这并不能最直接地反驳报纸Daily Clarion对Gotham City人的生活关注不及报纸Daily Bugle。
而D项中提到的报纸Daily Bugle的总编以及所有编辑部的职工都是在Gotham City工作生活至少十年的，这个信息就说明了报纸Daily Bugle的新闻对Gotham City人的生活关注是很高的，也保证了该报纸的信息质量。由于题目中的观点强调"Read the Daily Clarion, the only real voice of the people of Gotham City!"，认为报纸Daily Clarion是唯一反映Gotham City人们心声的报纸。而D项的这条信息正正反驳了这一点。
纯属个人观点，不当之处请各位多多指教。

S: 这道题应该是CR的吧，怎么出现在语法区的？

sweetbecky · 发表于 2011-10-3 13:32:27

文章的逻辑链是：

B是外省办的——C报纸比B好。
削弱：B的编辑都是本省的。反驳了条件。

而B选项中，说的是C有更多版面报道外省的消息。
完全是无关选项，根本不在逻辑推导链中。

大家来讨论一下这道题

所属分类: 下线版块

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()