885,SEC 13,8 　问题

大全660
660. Some biographers have not only disputed the common notion that Edgar Allan Poe drank to excess but also questioned whether he drank at all.
(A) have not only disputed the common notion that Edgar Allan Poe drank to excess but also questioned whether he drank
(B) not only have disputed the common notion that Edgar Allan Poe drank to excess but also over whether he drank
(C) have disputed not only the common notion that Edgar Allan Poe drank to excess but also whether he may not have drunk
(D) not only have disputed the common notion that Edgar Allan Poe drank to excess but also questioned whether or not he had drunk
(E) have disputed the common notion not only that Edgar Allan Poe drank to excess but also questioned whether he may not have drunk

答案是Ａ

a ,c ,d先不管其他。因为有人说意思有点区别我直接选ｃ　因为后面at all　每次句子念通顺都是前面是否定或直接出现ｎｏｔ的时候后面才用at all　所以把Ａ　排出了

除了说句意有变化的同志们以外。Ａ，Ｃ　还有那里有区别？？导致必须选A？

没看懂你说的区别法。

选项里面只有C是平行的。其他都不。

a和c的区别：

1。时态whether he drank《》whether he may not have drunk

后者罗索，may intrusive 而且没有必要用完成时，因为要说明的是过去的事实，用完成时有过去这样，现在不这样的意思

2。c的disputed接了the common notion that Edgar Allan Poe drank to excess ，whether he may not have drunk，后者用dispute不恰当，不能正确表达意思，用questioned more clearly

以下是引用麻集爱在2004-4-7 12:25:00的发言：
阿　找到同志拉～ 可惜人家ETS选A

8好意思。写错了，是只有A平衡，其他都不。

c的disputed接了the common notion that Edgar Allan Poe drank to excess ，whether he may not have drunk，后者用dispute不恰当，不能正确表达意思，用questioned more clearly

不同意。问什么不恰当？不能正确表达意？。 好像说服没有穿透力 。我还是想问后面的at all 不是给not搭配的是干吗的？

dispute查过了W-M,1.call into question2. to struggle against,

看来是我错了

at all 我也不清楚，习惯用法是not...at all,所以也想问问