一道题！！

linlin315 · 发表于 2003-8-17 21:29:00

A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published, reveals that Twain provided financial assistance to one of the first Black students at Yale Law School.
A. A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published,
B. A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year of publication as The Adventures of Huchleberry Finn,
C. A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year that The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn was published,
D. Mark Twain wrote a letter in the same year as he published The Adventures of Huchleberry Finn that
E. Mark Twain wrote a letter in the same year of publication as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn that
答案是C
我疑惑的是C中的that指带是什么？？year吗？？可是应该是the Adventures of the Huckleberry Finn was publishes in the year啊？所以应该用when或者是in which才对啊？
如果A选项把were改为was，用the same year as 的结构是不是更好呢？？？

sunder · 发表于 2003-8-17 21:48:00

it seems both " the same...as" and "the same...that" are qualified structures when we refer to comparison of time. There would be 2 right choices if choice A underwent such revision, I suppose.

mindfree · 发表于 2003-8-17 22:00:00

Personally I think "as" is not needed here. For example:

This is the same book (that) I borrowed last time.

"As" is a pronoun in "such as" and it is the same as "that", "which" or "who".

joywzy · 发表于 2003-8-18 06:26:00

agree with mindfree.

There is a Sc exercise in which as is omitted.

RMSF · 发表于 2003-8-18 10:32:00

nice to see the familar image of yours , really !

1068 topics?! YY pf you , BB!

as 是不可行的，因为是要用来修饰 year的，that 的作用有点象： It is in 1998 that I traveled .
但是这题没有A的 were我肯定还要错! 因为要理解透实在对我不易。

linlin315 · 发表于 2003-8-18 11:56:00

free哥哥的那句话兔兔同意，that做定从的宾语嘛！！当然可以省略了。但是这个
written in the same year that The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn was published, 我认为不对啊？？因为The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn was published in the year.所以应该用in which或者是when啊？怎么可以用that来指带in the same year呢？
还有这个as省略的问题？the same as是固定搭配，有的GMAT的错误选项就是因为少了as导致固定搭配不对才错的了？怎么回事啊？？

以下是引用mindfree在2003-8-17 22:00:00的发言：
Personally I think "as" is not needed here. For example:

This is the same book (that) I borrowed last time.

"As" is a pronoun in "such as" and it is the same as "that", "which" or "who".

beortobe · 发表于 2003-8-18 14:04:00

the same year as＝the same year that，其中的as是作为关系代词使用；如果
A中的were改成单数也是正确的；

the same as（介词）是固定搭配，但the same that（关系代词）也是可以的，只是以前我们很少用而已，所以看着就不顺眼；

白勇说，见到the same year之后加that肯定没有错，本人看来还是应该区别对待。

sunder · 发表于 2003-8-18 14:23:00

请问是OG哪一道，解释有提到as的存在被认为是wordy么？

same + N. + (that-)clause 是很常用和标准的方法，读起来也肯定很顺。
same总是修饰名词，名词后可以被that从句修饰，名词在从句里做宾语时that总会省。那same...as的用法似乎是多余了？
问题是，当焦点不在N.上而在比较上的时候， as是不是有必要，或者，会不会让人觉得wordy？

to lin, 我觉得这是一个惯用法，修饰时间的时候是可以这么用的，不用钻到句子成分里去了。

以下是引用joywzy在2003-8-18 6:26:00的发言：
agree with mindfree.

There is a Sc exercise in which as is omitted.

linlin315 · 发表于 2003-8-18 14:36:00

OG174

sunder · 发表于 2003-8-18 15:05:00

thanks.
e...the my question above is for joy....

以下是引用linlin315在2003-8-18 14:36:00的发言：
OG174

一道题！！

一道题！！

可是...

所属分类: 下线版块

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()