关于it用法和violate主语问题

lemon123 · 发表于 2014-9-23 14:40:53

求问各位大神，小弟在做练习中遇到这个题目：

According to the Better Business Bureau, if you fail to advertise the highest price in a range of prices for a service or product as prominently as that of the lowest, it violates the New York Consumer Protection Law.
(A) if you fail to advertise the highest price in a range of prices for a service or product as prominently as that of the lowest, it
(B) if one fails to advertise the highest price in a range of prices for a service or product as prominently as the lowest price, it
(C) failure to advertise the highest price in a range of prices for a service or product as prominently as the lowest
(D) failure to advertise as prominently the highest price in a range of prices for a service or product as the lowest
(E) failing to advertise as prominently the highest price in a range of prices for a service or products as that of the lowest

小弟选B，但给出的答案是C，理由是后面的it不能指代前面的状语从句，但这个理由仍然无法解答小弟疑惑：
1. violate的主语难道不应该是人吗？既然去违反一个规定或法律，应该是人去违反才对，而且Merriam Webster Learner给出的解释也是to break the laws or regulations；
2. B中后面的it难道不能指代前面性别不明的one吗？

lemon123 · 发表于 2014-9-23 14:48:06

先顶一个

lemon123 · 发表于 2014-9-23 14:51:12

求各在线大神回复，在线等，急！！！

lemon123 · 发表于 2014-9-23 17:22:41

再顶一个...

bigfatwhiterabb · 发表于 2014-9-25 10:38:38

1. 确切的说应该是xx行为违反了xx规定，我们在汉语也是这么说啊，你的行为违反了xx条例。
1. 楼主都说了违反的是人，确切的说施动者是人，那么one指代的是人，it怎么能指代人呢？

lemon123 · 发表于 2014-9-26 13:47:43

bigfatwhiterabb 发表于 2014-9-25 10:38
1. 确切的说应该是xx行为违反了xx规定，我们在汉语也是这么说啊，你的行为违反了xx条例。
1. 楼主都说了违 ...

原来如此！以前对one作代词的用法没去深入了解。多谢大神回复！

关于it用法和violate主语问题

所属分类: 下线版块

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()