ChaseDream
搜索
12下一页
返回列表 发新帖
查看: 10902|回复: 12
打印 上一主题 下一主题

[SC悬赏令] 求助大神版主们 OG16 SC Q21 VS Q101 as with的问题

[复制链接]
跳转到指定楼层
楼主
发表于 2015-8-17 21:42:21 | 只看该作者 回帖奖励 |倒序浏览 |阅读模式
21 Thai village crafts, as with other cultures, have developed through the principle that form follows function and incorporate readily available materials fashioned using traditional skills.
(A) as with
(B) as did those of
(C) as they have in
(D) like in
(E) like those of
OA E

og解释:The phrase as with other cultures is initially confusing given that no culture has been specifically mentioned; Thai village culture is indirectly referenced by the mention of Thai village crafts, so perhaps that is what is meant. But then, looking at the phrase in context, it becomes clear that the sentence is intended to indicate
that the crafts of other cultures are similar in certain ways to Thai village crafts. Thus, the sentence should say those of other cultures. Furthermore, the use here of as with is questionable. To do the job it is supposed to do here (to indicate that the crafts of Thai villages are like the crafts of other cultures in a particular way), as with should be at the beginning of the sentence: As with the crafts of other cultures, Thai village crafts have developed . . . . Alternatively, like could be used here instead of as with.



101. Similar to other early Mississippi Delta blues singers, the music of Robert Johnson arose from an oral tradition beginning with a mixture of chants, fiddle tunes, and religious music and only gradually evolved into the blues.
(A) Similar to other early Mississippi Delta blues singers, the music of Robert Johnson arose from an oral tradition beginning with
(B) Similar to that of other early Mississippi Delta blues singers, Robert Johnson made music that arose from an oral tradition that began with
(C) As with other early Mississippi Delta blues singers, Robert Johnson made music that arose from an oral tradition beginning as
(D) Like other early Mississippi Delta blues singers, Robert Johnson’s music arose from an oral tradition beginning with
(E) Like the music of other early Mississippi Delta blues singers, the music of Robert Johnson arose from an oral tradition that began as

OA E


og对c选项解释
C The comparative phrase as with is an inappropriate form for comparing nouns and noun phrases. The second half of the sentence violates parallelism, attempting to express the first stage of the oral tradition as a present-participle phrase and the second as a past-tense verb phrase.


其他的正确错误原因不多说了,我的问题在于为什么在21题中as with可以替代like,而在101题中as with就不能比较noun了呢?这是自相矛盾吗?求助各路大神解答,多谢!!!



收藏收藏3 收藏收藏3
沙发
发表于 2015-8-18 01:49:44 | 只看该作者
我仔细读了OG的解释,感觉GMAC是再说,as with在表达similar的意思上是questionable的,但是如果一定要用,那么就是表达它们在一定程度上like,就要将as with前置到句首,并且服从like的句法和主句主语严格对等,而且like也是对的。
这句话我翻译的不好,但是GMAC明显是带着一种让步,比如”如果一定要这样吧,那么..."的,所以as with和like,比较对象都一样的前提下,用like不要用as with。

贴一下PREP08对于as with的总结:
as with的结构在日常语法中是对的(意思为“正如……的情况一样”, 看作是as is the same with的省略式,with 后面常跟名词、动名词或what从句),但用于GMAT语法中,需要有其他结构与之平行:
With diamonds, as with all gems, you should ask for a written description of your purchase; the description may prove useful later if you have reason to believe the jeweler misled you.
板凳
 楼主| 发表于 2015-8-18 06:01:39 | 只看该作者
骡子桑 发表于 2015-8-18 01:49
我仔细读了OG的解释,感觉GMAC是再说,as with在表达similar的意思上是questionable的,但是如果一定要用, ...

嗯,你说的有道理,非常谢谢。就是prep08的例句我认为给的有点巧,正好开头是with diamonds,所以as后加了个with。
地板
发表于 2015-12-3 13:51:24 | 只看该作者
看了OG16Q101的解释,是说as with 在这里不合适是比较了名词和名词词组。感觉会不会是as with的比较非常严格,必须是名词与名词比较,名词词组和名词词组比较呢?Q21中OG中举的例子也是as with the crafts of other cultures, Thai village crafts hae developed...  
当然可以用like的地方就不要用as with。 记得OG说过能用一个词的地方就不要用两个词。==
感觉自己的解释也挺牵强的,请大家多多指正哈~
5#
发表于 2016-1-15 15:35:55 | 只看该作者
同問!
且Manhattan在比較like及AS時,有說
"Comparsion As can also appear with a phrase,rather than a full clause.
Right:As in the previous case,the judge took an early break."
請各位大牛幫忙解惑一下,謝謝!
6#
发表于 2016-3-27 11:21:14 | 只看该作者
骡子桑 发表于 2015-8-18 01:49
我仔细读了OG的解释,感觉GMAC是再说,as with在表达similar的意思上是questionable的,但是如果一定要用, ...

那为什么21题OG解释说如果用as with也可以,但是必须放句首呢?
而且Thai village crafts中也不存在with
7#
发表于 2016-3-27 20:40:40 | 只看该作者
锕儍 发表于 2016-3-27 11:21
那为什么21题OG解释说如果用as with也可以,但是必须放句首呢?
而且Thai village crafts中也不存在with ...

As with这个用法不被GMAC认可。

GMAC只接受as is the case with。

TN24-Q29: As it is with traditional pharmacies, online drugstores rely on prescriptions to be successful, since it is primarily prescriptions that attract the customers, who then also buy other health-related items.

A. As it is with traditional pharmacies, online drugstores rely on prescriptions to be successful
B. As with the case of traditional pharmacies, online drugstores rely on prescriptions to have success
C. As is the case with traditional pharmacies, prescriptions are the cornerstone of a successful online drugstore
D. As traditional pharmacies, so online drugstores rely on prescriptions to be successful
E. Like traditional pharmacies, the cornerstone of a successful online drugstore is prescriptions
OA:C
8#
发表于 2016-7-30 09:57:14 | 只看该作者
OG原题A选项是这么解释的:
A The appropriate comparison is between Thai village crafts and those i.e., crafts of other cultures, not the other cultures themselves. Additionally, like would be more appropriate here than as with.
可以理解为GMAC认为like>as with,尽管二者语法上都正确。
9#
发表于 2016-7-30 12:48:48 | 只看该作者
这两题的答案是啥?EE么
10#
发表于 2016-9-18 22:45:45 | 只看该作者
In Choice C As + prepositional phrase does not work in the context of this sentence because the main clause contains an action that needs to be compared with another action after as. This action is missing in Choice C.
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 立即注册

Mark一下! 看一下! 顶楼主! 感谢分享! 快速回复:

IESE MBA
近期活动

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()

手机版|ChaseDream|GMT+8, 2024-12-4 04:40
京公网安备11010202008513号 京ICP证101109号 京ICP备12012021号

ChaseDream 论坛

© 2003-2023 ChaseDream.com. All Rights Reserved.

返回顶部