求助 OG2017V-SC-258！！夹心修饰问题

投机取巧的leezy · 发表于 2019-10-22 21:51:05

Even though the overall consumer price index did not change in April, indicating the absence of any general inflation or deflation, prices in several categories of merchandise have fallen over the last several months.

AApril, indicating the absence of any general inflation or deflation, prices in several categories of merchandise have fallen
BApril, indicating that any general inflation or deflation were absent, prices in several categories of merchandise fell
CApril and indicated that absence of any general inflation or deflation, prices in several categories of merchandise fell
DApril, having indicated the absence of any general inflation or deflation, prices in several categories of merchandise fell （A）
EApril, which indicated that any general inflation or deflation were absent, prices in several categories of merchandise have fallen
A不会引起夹心修饰吗？？？

momoyi · 发表于 2019-10-22 22:36:36

从语法上来说，会。
prices可以被indicating the absence of any general inflation or deflation所修饰。

但是形成夹心修饰的决定性条件是产生歧义，即使语法上是夹心修饰，但句意上不产生歧义，那么就不是夹心修饰。
prices indicating the absence of any general inflation or deflation
大家都明白的一点就是，单单价格是不可能导致升值和贬值的缺失
而消费者指数的固定才能导致升值和贬值的缺失

那么就意味着，很难会有gmat考生会去认为价格会导致这个结果。
因此就不会产生句意上的歧义，那么这个夹心修饰就不成立。
间接说明，GMAT考的不是纯语法，而是考生对题目的理解。

投机取巧的leezy · 发表于 2019-10-22 22:54:22

momoyi 发表于 2019-10-22 22:36
从语法上来说，会。
prices可以被indicating the absence of any general inflation or deflation所修饰。
...

感谢感谢看来还是语义最重要

李姿GMAT700 · 发表于 2021-1-18 03:16:57

momoyi 发表于 2019-10-22 22:36
从语法上来说，会。
prices可以被indicating the absence of any general inflation or deflation所修饰。
...

讲的真好，赞一个！

求助 OG2017V-SC-258！！夹心修饰问题

所属分类: 下线版块

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()