princeton模考中的一道题-->古镯转移

A. The first political passengers on modern railroads cars were a president, a senator, and a governor, who travel to Washington, D.C. together or the Liberty Express in 1907.

B. A president, a senator, and a governor were the first political passengers on modern railroad cars who traveled to Washington, D.C. together or the Liberty Express in 1907.

答案为A，我认为是B。

A中的who是指代passengers，还是指代  a governor？并且A中用的是现在时态travel。

B我觉得没错。who就是指代passengers.

我还不太清楚代词who，which，that等究竟是指代紧靠的名词还是可以指代更前面的名词，要是who，which，that前面有逗号，这是是不是只指代紧靠前面的名词。

请NN们指教。

再举个例子OG的85题

Out of America's fascination with all things antique has grown a market for bygone styles of furniture and fixtures that is bringing back the chaise lounge, the overstruffed sofa, and the claw-footed bathtub.

这里的that就指代market，可that与market隔了那么远。

如果改为that are是不是就指代styles?

下周就考了，知识点还没有弄懂

      我觉得还是B好一点

      A中 travel 该是过去时态

     指代唯一的法则就是逻辑意思

就是呵，A明显是错的嘛。og说过who/whom只能指代人嘛（那道题是说一群人里有些人是盲人，one of whom是正确选项），那这里显然就是强制指代嘛，修饰宾语passengers. A显然有指代和时态上的错误啊？这又不是客观公理，就算是也是指代a governor应该用travels呵.

下周考呵，加油了mm，祝福ing……

谢谢各位xdjm，我正在加油

A. The first political passengers on modern railroads cars were a president, a senator, and a governor, who travel to Washington, D.C. together or the Liberty Express in 1907.

B. A president, a senator, and a governor were the first political passengers on modern railroad cars who traveled to Washington, D.C. together or the Liberty Express in 1907.

A中的travel时态不对

但B也不对呀, who应该修饰a president, a senator, and a governor, 但在B中错误地修饰了the first political passengers, 改变了原句的意思

B   的意思好像不对， 在 b 里 由于没了who修饰， a president, a senator and a governor 是泛指，就好像说：任何一个president一个governor和一个senator 就是第一批做railroad car的乘客。。。

A如果把travel改成过去时态，就是对的了。

我觉得B不对，首先B改变了句子的重心，原文强调的是passengers是有什么人组成的，而B却强调的是这些人是passengers,仔细体会一下，是有区别的。

who修饰的对象应该是a president, a senator, and a governor，他们一起travel。