AS WELLas 矛盾题目怀疑PREP答案

alicejingli

现在先看这个：The first shots of the American Revolution, fired at Lexington and Concord
, Massachusetts, were, according to legend, heard around the world, but news of these shots, which were sent by swift messenger, took four days in reaching New York City as well as another additional eleven days to reach Charleston, South Carolina.
A.shots, which were sent by swift messenger, took four days in reaching New York City
as well as another additional eleven days
B.shots that was sent by swift messenger took four days in order to reach New York City
, and also another eleven days
C.shots that were sent by swift messenger took four days to reach New York City
and another eleven days
D.shots took four days by swift messenger in order to reach New York City
and another eleven days in addition(E)
E.shots took four days by swift messenger to reach New York City
and another eleven days
as well as 与and 的意思不完全一致，作为习语用作介词时，as well as的涵义是“还有”、“不但…而且…”。值得注意的是，在A as well as B的结构里，语意的重点在 A，不在 B。因此，要注意句子想要表达的逻辑关系
这个都没有问题，我的问题是，我做一道PREP--1（新）当时考察的是 ...(省略）...........for women as well as for man
这个选项里面就有 and for man, as well as for man但是答案却选择了 as well as for man.
可是按照上面那个分析，as well as 不是不引导平行吗！！！！所以求解，谁能告诉我！！！

AlohaDJ

lz能不能把那道有问题的题贴上来看看

alicejingli

lz能不能把那道有问题的题贴上来看看

-- by 会员 AlohaDJ (2010/12/21 18:56:20)

197. In the fall of 1985, only 10 percent of the women entering college planned to major in education, while 28 percent chose business, making it the most popular major for women as well as for men.
(A)    as well as for men
(B)    as well as the men
(C)    and men too
(D)    and men as well
(E)    and also men

piacia

额，上面这题感觉是A，对吗，如果强求C的话我觉得需要变成and for men as well。。。
不是NN。。语法极差。。大家讨论

AlohaDJ

as well as和and，二者逻辑意思有差别，正如lz解释清楚的，但并不是说as well as不能引导平行结构，正如2楼的题目。如果lz实在想用and，可五个选项中没有and for men。

alicejingli

不是，没有for是for 省略了，这个是对的以前XDF老师说过可以的，所以我才想问   这个选项里面就有 and man, as well as for man但是答案却选择了 as well as for man.
可是按照上面那个分析，as well as 不是不引导平行吗！！！！所以求解，谁能告诉我！！！

wudiyeah

主句是表述10%women  planned to major in education，28% women choose business, making引导状语从句表示这个现象导致的结果

原句想表达的意思应该是：女人们在专业上的选择(10%education, 28%business)，使business成为了女性们的首选（然后顺带提一下它在男人中也是最受欢迎的专业，所以用as well as 了，表达了句意的倾向性）

而不是：女人们在专业上的选择(10%education, 28%business)，使得business成为了男人女人都首选。——前后逻辑就不对了

所以用and 的话不对