ChaseDream

标题: OG13-86与正确答案无关，被一个选项困住 In 2000, a mere two dozen products [打印本页]

作者: lalapiao 时间: 2012-7-10 21:29
标题: OG13-86与正确答案无关，被一个选项困住 In 2000, a mere two dozen products
题： In 2000, a mere two dozen products accounted for half the increase in spending on prescription drugs, a phenomenon that is explained not just because of more expensive drugs but by the fact that doctors are writing many more prescriptions for higher-cost drugs.

A.a phenomenon that is explained not just because of more expensive drugs but by the fact that doctors are writing
B.a phenomenon that is explained not just by the fact that drugs are becoming more expensive but also by the fact that doctors are writing
C.a phenomenon occurring not just because of drugs that are becoming more expensive but because of doctors having also written
D.which occurred not just because drugs are becoming more expensive but doctors are also writing
E.which occurred not just because of more expensive drugs but because doctors have also written
我想问的是：C 选项的 a phenomenon occurring没有错么？我认为是错误的，不过og没有提到。。。求解释！！！
ps：其他选项和解释已明白，可能会觉得我太钻牛角尖了。。。不过，目前为止除了个别题og的解释都很让我心服口服，除了极少数题的解释模糊或者错误没有指出以外。（所以我很怀疑，是不是自己的认为的错误其实是正确的。。）

作者: superbat28 时间: 2012-7-11 14:23
从语法上来说a phenomenon occurring是没有错误的。occurring是V-ing形式的动名词做后置定语，修饰phenomenon

但是，再扣细一点，V-ing后置定语在这里不如AB 的 that从句（尽管都是定语功能）。因为V-ing更适合于法律条文，比如 the law suggesting.... 这样有【重复适用发生】意味的情况。而that从句，更适用于单一次数发生的情况

作者: jiaoguitar 时间: 2012-7-12 02:09
还有becase of的使用也不符合OG对because/ because of的偏好。because of 最好只跟一个名词，不要出现从句，否则就用because。另外n. + having done也是GMAC极其不喜欢的结构。

作者: lalapiao 时间: 2012-7-12 15:17

从语法上来说a phenomenon occurring是没有错误的。occurring是V-ing形式的动名词做后置定语，修饰phenomenon

但是，再扣细一点，V-ing后置定语在这里不如AB 的 that从句（尽管都是定语功能）。因为V-ing更适合于法律条文，比如 the law suggesting.... 这样有【重复适用发生】意味的情况。而that从句，更适用于单一次数发生的情况

-- by 会员 superbat28 (2012/7/11 14:23:05)

谢谢!!
大无畏精神再次提问：定语的时候，如果我没记错的话，只有可用作形容词的动名词才可以的。。。吗？（不确定不确定。。）
还有就是，我一直把occur当做瞬间动词，所以occurring这个用法觉得不适合。求赐教！！！

作者: lalapiao 时间: 2012-7-12 19:53

还有becase of的使用也不符合OG对because/ because of的偏好。because of 最好只跟一个名词，不要出现从句，否则就用because。另外n. + having done也是GMAC极其不喜欢的结构。

-- by 会员 jiaoguitar (2012/7/12 2:09:58)

恩恩，这个观点我赞同。谢谢你哈~

作者: 蛋蛋音 时间: 2012-7-20 12:39

-- by 会员 superbat28 (2012/7/11 14:23:05)

-- by 会员 lalapiao (2012/7/12 15:17:14)

貌似并不是的，只要前面名词时定语的逻辑主语就可以。但是个别题目也要看情况，有是有用that引导定语从句更好，虽然一般来说后置定语更简洁。

欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/)