标题: OG12-SC82 it和its指代不一致 [打印本页] 作者: kuan89 时间: 2011-4-10 22:48 标题: OG12-SC82 it和its指代不一致 82. According to a recent poll, owning and living in a freestanding house on its own land is still a goal of a majority of young adults, like that of earlier generations. A. like that of earlier generations B. as that for earlier generations C. just as earlier generations did D. as have earlier generations E. as it was of earlier generations
这题中未划线 its 和 正确选项E中 it 的指代貌似不一致 OG里说 it 指代 owning and living in a freestanding house on its own land
那么不是有同一个指代词指代不一致了吗？ 我看到it 就直接排除E了
请 NN 帮忙解释下。。这是为什么
谢谢作者: mlvince 时间: 2011-4-10 23:06
这题我也一直没搞懂，og解释上好像说e的it是指代前面一段话，可是很多地方都说it是不能指代一句话的。按以前的帖子，这题应该是优选吧作者: charles1987 时间: 2011-4-11 08:21
i will go for A (of course it is a wrong answer). but i actually wanna know, can "that" in choice A refer to "a goal" since OG said this "that" in choice A was ambiguous ?
for choice E, I HAD the same concern as the post here disgussed.
CAN YOU GUYS HELP ?作者: Gail小M 时间: 2011-4-11 10:05
it和its的确不一致.慧眼..
it refers to "owning and living in a freestanding house on its own land " >Not a sentence 只能是优选了.有见过一题是them和their指代不一致的.但这种都是很少的情况.并且its是在介词短语里，对原文的影响也会相对而言少一些.作者: longee 时间: 2011-4-11 10:44
以下仅代表个人观点 未划线部分有个still请注意，说这个依然是young adults的goal,正如前几代人一样。 所以我认为，as it was 这个句子是个省略句，不省略的话应该是as it was a goal of earlier generations. it 就指代了owning and living in a freestanding house on its own land. its可以替换为the house's 纯凭语感乱说话，呵呵如果不对希望大家也告诉我一下作者: Lusiazh1989 时间: 2011-6-23 07:07
its可以替换为the house's
-- by 会员 longee (2011/4/11 10:44:01)
单纯为这个its纠结一下。。。所以这个应该是 "owning and living in a freestanding house on the house's own land" ? 我纠结的点在于，这句话纯讨论意思的话，我的理解是：这个land应该是the young adults' own land.. 当然如果这么理解用its就肯定不对了。。这也是为什么，我觉得这个its有问题。如果理解成指代house's的话，在意思上觉得很别扭。 当然这句话是非划线部分，应该不会有错，就是不理解作者: tyzgmat 时间: 2011-6-23 10:53
摘抄一句 TONYADIDAS 的笔记送给你 （tip,若前句用的是所有格形式，后句的代词若想指代前句的所有者，是绝对错的）