ChaseDream

标题: GWD-23-Q20 no discussion found [打印本页]

作者: shanexwang    时间: 2006-11-16 05:50
标题: GWD-23-Q20 no discussion found

Both the Federal Reserve’s decision that borrowing rates be raised, along with investor’s speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making deposits more attractive.

 

  1. that borrowing rates be raised, along with investor’s speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making

  2. that borrowing rates be raised and investors’ speculation of possibly another increase on the way helped to bolster the dollar in recent weeks because they made

  3. to raise borrowing rates and investors’ speculation that another increase might be on the way helped to bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making

  4. to raise borrowing rates, along with investors’ speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks because it made

  5. to raise borrowing rates and investors’ speculation of possibly another increase on the way helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks because they made

i just wanna confirm the reason of eliminating  B

谢谢


作者: shanexwang    时间: 2006-11-17 12:53
谢谢
[此贴子已经被作者于2006-11-17 23:15:11编辑过]

作者: daijiabj    时间: 2006-11-17 22:35
B中的they没有指代,考试中的指代的错误很多,一般来讲应该是就近指代的,因为远距离指代很容易产生歧义,在本题种they指代的是weeks,必然错!! 
作者: shirley06296    时间: 2008-10-1 11:39
以下是引用daijiabj在2006-11-17 22:35:00的发言:
B中的they没有指代,考试中的指代的错误很多,一般来讲应该是就近指代的,因为远距离指代很容易产生歧义,在本题种they指代的是weeks,必然错!! 

我记得在另一关于指代的争议题中有版主认为不一定非得指代最近的词,也可根据题目的前后意思确定they指代的事物,请问难道考试中真的完全不管题意只是将they或it认为是指代离它最近的词吗?


作者: remona9t    时间: 2008-10-1 14:22
这道题答案是什么呢?

E?

作者: kelvinchyan    时间: 2008-10-1 14:35
如果要远距离指代的话也是用that而不可能用they,所以用they必然错啊
作者: furaolove    时间: 2008-10-23 10:20
还是不太明白,有没有NN能再解释一下阿??
作者: queenjie    时间: 2009-2-4 22:23
请牛人出来指点一下,这道题的they的指代问题
作者: smartsky11    时间: 2009-2-20 11:18

Both the Federal Reserve’s decision that borrowing rates be raised, along with investor’s speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making deposits more attractive.

A.      that borrowing rates be raised, along with investor’s speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making

B.       that borrowing rates be raised and investors’ speculation of possibly another increase on the way helped to bolster the dollar in recent weeks because they made

C.      to raise borrowing rates and investors’ speculation that another increase might be on the way helped to bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making

D.      to raise borrowing rates, along with investors’ speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks because it made

E.       to raise borrowing rates and investors’ speculation of possibly another increase on the way helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks because they made

of 不如that表示清楚,
            it
they 指代不清


作者: tiffany1102    时间: 2009-4-18 19:34
up
作者: 天蝎座1107    时间: 2009-4-18 19:42

Both the Federal Reserve’s decision that borrowing rates be raised, along with investor’s speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making deposits more attractive.

 

 

  1. that borrowing rates be raised, along with investor’s speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making  both...along with...错 helped前面没有必要逗号 decision不可以用decision that (should) be/动词原型 decision又不是requirement一类可以用虚拟语气的词

  2. that borrowing rates be raised and investors’ speculation of possibly another increase on the way helped to bolster the dollar in recent weeks because they made they指代错误

  3. to raise borrowing rates and investors’ speculation that another increase might be on the way helped to bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making

  4. to raise borrowing rates, along with investors’ speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks because it made both...along with错 helped前面没有必要逗号 it指代错误(试图指代了前面整句话)

  5. to raise borrowing rates and investors’ speculation of possibly another increase on the way helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks because they made这里they指代错误

作者: yy179920478    时间: 2009-7-30 21:03
up
作者: gmatwc    时间: 2009-8-6 11:49

Both the Federal Reserve’s decision that borrowing rates be raised, along with investor’s speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making deposits more attractive.

 

A.      that borrowing rates be raised, along with investor’s speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making

楼上说的对,1、along with错 2、helped错,主语与谓语间不能用逗号隔开。

3、第三点与11楼不同,decision可以用that做定语进行修饰,只是本题若用that修饰导致被动,而且表达没有简洁反而冗余复杂。同时,decision to raise borrowing rates, 说明了美联储决策的目的,而且也是主动表达,自然优于用that对decision做定语修饰。

B.      that borrowing rates be raised and investors’ speculation of possibly another increase on the way helped to bolster the dollar in recent weeks because they made

1、that的问题同A选项

2、 将might be 改为possibly不妥 

3、与11楼不同,关于they指代,原则上是就近指代,但不绝对。我认为这个they是指代主语没问题,我认为是逻辑错误。

      原文要说的是,美联储的贷款利率提升决策和投资人的投机性(贷款利率高了,自然就不投资转而存钱了)会支撑美元,通过使得储蓄更具吸引力。

      B选项,用because,逻辑意思变为,因为他们让储蓄更具吸引力了,所以美联和投资人投机帮助了支撑美元,这是实际逻辑不符。

     事实上,提高贷款利率,和投资人的投资性,主观客观上使得储蓄更具吸引力。逻辑上,颠倒了因果关系。

C.      to raise borrowing rates and investors’ speculation that another increase might be on the way helped to bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making

1、to do 表明了政策要提利率

2、that 修饰了investors' speculation

D.      to raise borrowing rates, along with investors’ speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks because it made

错误同上,且 it 无指代

E.       to raise borrowing rates and investors’ speculation of possibly another increase on the way helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks because they made

错误同上

一点浅见,请指正


作者: kevinli120    时间: 2009-8-31 11:13

Both the Federal Reserve’s decision that borrowing rates be raised, along with investor’s speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making deposits more attractive.

 

 

A.   that borrowing rates be raised, along with investor’s speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making

B.   that
                    
borrowing rates be raised and investors’ speculation
                        of
possibly another increase on the way helped to bolster the dollar in recent weeks because they made

C.   to raise borrowing rates and investors’ speculation that another increase might be on the way helped to bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making

D.  to raise borrowing rates, along with investors’ speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks because it made

E.   to raise borrowing rates and investors’ speculation of possibly another increase on the way helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks because they made

    AD肯定错了,BCE讨论,D的it肯定指代错误。姑且不看they指代Both A and B中的AB可不可以(个人认为they指代没有问题),BE中加了because,这个是原文没有的一层逻辑意思,原文用by表示方式,所以排除BE,选C。这是我的解题思路。

open to discussion


[此贴子已经被作者于2009/8/31 11:13:47编辑过]

作者: mars_cheung    时间: 2009-10-25 15:41

同意13楼的分析

B 的错误在于两个:错用虚拟语气;错用因果逻辑。相比之下,they 指代主句的主语我觉得是可行和清晰的。


作者: lxw19    时间: 2010-3-28 11:00
但是感觉C选项不平行啊~~
作者: lisa83    时间: 2010-4-8 11:54
请NN再解释一下C项的平行问题
C.    (to raise borrowing rates )and investors’ speculation (that another increase might be on the way) helped to bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making
认为一个是介词短语,一个是that从句,平行吗?MS要严格平行的吧
作者: 切尔西    时间: 2010-4-8 14:21
# that borrowing rates be raised, along with investor’s speculation that another increase might be on the way, helped bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making

# that borrowing rates be raised and investors’ speculation of possibly another increase on the way helped to bolster the dollar in recent weeks because they made

# to raise borrowing rates and investors’ speculation that another increase might be on the way helped to bolster the dollar in recent weeks by making

B选项中删除了原句中的情态动词might, 在GMAT考试中情态动词不可以随意添加或者删改,替换;
另外,原句中使用了by making 这里强调动作,而B选项中用了because they made强调了结果,改变句子意思
还有大家都说到的they指代不清楚,导致歧义
作者: jedylxl    时间: 2010-7-5 19:50
顺便问一声,help to do 的to到底要不要省啊
作者: dephie    时间: 2010-7-15 23:45
顺便问一声,help to do 的to到底要不要省啊
-- by 会员 jedylxl (2010/7/5 19:50:03)


这个可省可不省,没有特别的要求,两种都对的~
作者: 00willa00    时间: 2010-12-29 14:35
1both…and… 排除A D
2.忠于原句:might be情态动词不可随意删改;bymaking表方式,because增加因果关系,排除B E
3OG曰:of possibly anotherincrease wordy and akwardthey可指代investorsambigous
作者: ssxxtt27    时间: 2011-9-1 00:07
B选项还有一个错误
investors’ speculation of possibly another increase on the way
on the way介词短语跟在名词后要格外注意 在这里逻辑上修饰的increase  但是也可以看做修饰speculation 这就歧义了
C中用that很巧妙的避开了这个问题
作者: zhenltian84    时间: 2011-9-1 06:08
选c.
作者: ssxxtt27    时间: 2011-9-2 23:31
decision后面不加that加to?对吗?
作者: 糊涂的小黑    时间: 2011-9-3 09:19
investors’ speculation of possibly another increase 这个表述非常wordy
作者: Jane412    时间: 2011-11-29 17:32
同意13楼和17楼的分析,只是那个平行结构怎么解释呢?虽然这题可能的选项里都不平行。。。。




欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3