GWD4-Q4 确定是C？

m8888302

A new hair-growing drug is being sold for three times the price, per milligram, as the drug’s maker charges for another
product with the same active ingredient.


A. as

B. than

C. that

D. of what

E. at which

答案是C，我给的版本上说有争议是D。查了用法，有X times the n. (that…)
那D这种名词后面加of+名词性从句，不对？
求真相

estilada

为啥Ｂ不对呢

2008115061

我觉得选C  先把句子意思读懂。前者的要价是后者的三倍。
B后半句话没有verb, leading to a sentence fragment.

这句话前面已经说the price, 后面直接用that可以填补后半句的宾语。

estilada

我觉得选C  先把句子意思读懂。前者的要价是后者的三倍。
B后半句话没有verb, leading to a sentence fragment.

这句话前面已经说the price, 后面直接用that可以填补后半句的宾语。

-- by 会员 2008115061 (2010/8/23 17:31:35)

that是否既是后半句的宾语，同时that 后接的句子也是同位语来修饰price呢？我对这个有点不明白。。

estilada

A new hair-growing drug is being sold for three times the price, per milligram, as the drug’s maker charges for another
product with the same active ingredient.


A. as

B. than

C. that

D. of what

E. at which

答案是C，我给的版本上说有争议是D。查了用法，有X times the n. (that…)
那D这种名词后面加of+名词性从句，不对？
求真相

-- by 会员 m8888302 (2010/8/22 19:45:54)

我觉得不会是D,因为固定用法是charge sb xxdollar for sth, 那就应该没有介词+从句吧

luoxlucy88

D解释：
3 times of sth， what是maker charge的price，引导名词性从句。
所以就是A new hair-growing drug is being sold for three times the price of（ the price）
一个价格是另一个价格的三倍，逻辑意思蛮正确。

而C中that做charges的宾语应该省略吧。直接变成3 times the price the drug’s maker charges for….即可。

所以个人观点，应该选d。仅供参考。。

chasedreamjj

D解释：
3 times of sth， what是maker charge的price，引导名词性从句。
所以就是A new hair-growing drug is being sold for three times the price of（ the price）
一个价格是另一个价格的三倍，逻辑意思蛮正确。

而C中that做charges的宾语应该省略吧。直接变成3 times the price the drug’s maker charges for….即可。

所以个人观点，应该选d。仅供参考。。

-- by 会员 luoxlucy88 (2010/8/28 18:02:03)

我看了语法书  貌似动词引导的宾语从句在正式语体中that不能省

hanlei8492

转自http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_4edde3060100bait.html

为了方便分析，把插入成分per milligram去掉
句子变成
A new hair-growing drug is being sold for three times the price——the drug’s maker charges for another product with the same active ingredient.
在空格中应该填入什么呢
答案是that
that引导定语从句，修饰price，that在从句中做charges的宾语（charge的用法：charges ten dollars for a haircut）
为什么选that？
看以下例题
tom的年龄是jerry的3倍，

这样的句意通常可以有三种表示方法：
1 tom is twice older than jerry
2 tom is 3 times as old as jerry
3 tom is 3 times the age of jerry
可以看出，此题和第3种的表达方法类似，只不过把后置定语of jerry改成定语从句而已
此题最容易误选的of what
为什么错？
what = the thing that 在此题中=the price that
选of what则意味
3 times the price of the price that the drug's maker charges for
错误已经很明显了

此题的争议也可以告一段落

angela7258

好贴！

bunengwangmima

不错，顶