OG13 SC 113国外一个帖子的想法

abc791201064

113. As a babvemergesfrom the darknessof the womb
witha rudimentarysenseofvision,it wouldberated
about20/500.orlegally blindif it wereanadultwith
suchvision.
(A) As a babyemergesfrom the darknessof the
womb with a rudimentarysenseof vision, it
would be ratedabout20/500,or legallyblindif
it werean adultwithsuchvision.
(B) A babyemergesfrom the darknessof the womb
with arudimentarysenseof visionthatwould be
rated about20/500,or legally blind as an adult.
(C) As a babyemergesfrom the darknessof the
womb, its rudimentarysenseof vision would be
rated about 20/500;qualifyingit to be legally
blindif anadult.
(D) A babyemergesfrom the darknessofthewomb
with a rudimentarysenseof vision that would be
ratedabout20/500;anadultwithsuchvision
would bedeemedlegally blind.
(E) As a babyemergesfrom the darknessof the
womb, its rudimentarysenseofvision,which
woulddeemedlegally blind for an adult, would
beratedabout20/500.


GMAT CLUB一个帖子这么写的
我感觉有点颠覆我的语法观  难道后面是its 前面的先行词就不能是baby么？
(E) As a baby emerges from the darkness of the womb, its rudimentary sense of vision, which would deemed legally blind for an adult, would be rated about 20/500.

E is also wrong because the answer choice uses "its". "Its" is a possessive pronoun, for which it needs to have a possessive noun in the beginning to make sense of it. There isn't a possessive noun in the beginning, but only "a baby emerges...". The only way to make sense of the possessive pronoun (its) is if the answer choice began with the construction of "baby's vision", rather than "a baby" alone. Otherwise, the usage of "its" is out of place and has no direct referent.

摇曳的叶子

“我感觉有点颠覆我的语法观  难道后面是its 前面的先行词就不能是baby么？”

可以指代

ps：可以编排一下么，看起来好累。

墨苒

好像前几天看到manhattan上有写所有格形式的代词只能指代所有格……如果我没记错的话……

之前看解答都没发现这个点诶！