急求！！大全test Ⅲ 第16题！求大牛指导！！

竹灵溪月

16. A violin constructed to have improved sound would sound different from the best-sounding existing violins.
To professional violinists, a violin that sounds different from the best-sounding existing violins sounds less like a violin and therefore worse than the best-sounding existing violins.
Professional violinists are the only accepted judges of the sound quality of violins.
Would be the best supported by those statements?
(A) Only amateur violinists should be asked to judge the sound quality of newly constructed violins.
(B) Professional violinists supervise the construction of violins.
(C) The best-sounding existing violins have been in existence fro several centuries.
(D) It is currently impossible to construct a violin that the only accepted judges will evaluate as having improved sound.
(E) It is possible to construct a violin that sounds better than the best-sounding existing violins to everyone but professional violinists.






正确答案是D，我选了E，但是我对D和E的理解都有点晕……希望大牛能指导！！




不胜感激！！

sdcar2010

Must be true type of question.

D is must-be-true according to the passage.

E) on the other hand, is possible, but is not must-be-true according to the passage.

chasingM7

as per E, "sounds better than the best-sounding existing violins to everyone" is not mentioned anywhere in the statement.

but for D, it is a summary of what arguments try to say.

竹灵溪月

还是不是很清楚，为什么must be true就是正确的答案呢？

望更深入指导！！谢谢！！

竹灵溪月

也就是说，sounds better than the best-sounding existing violins to everyone是一个在原文中没有提及的信息，所以E选项就可以用无关信息排除了？

可是D选项还是不是很明白为什么是正确的，我的理解（不知道对不对）是：
1 have improved sound的violin 和 best-sound的声音有区别；
2 对于专业的violinists而言，跟best-sound有区别的violin就是声音没它好的violin，因此就是比best-sound violin差的；
3 专业violinist是唯一可以评价音质的人。


而D是：现在不可能制造一个被专业violinist评价为have improved sound的violin






这里面的逻辑还是不清楚……
跪求解答……

sdcar2010

也就是说，sounds better than the best-sounding existing violins to everyone是一个在原文中没有提及的信息，所以E选项就可以用无关信息排除了？

可是D选项还是不是很明白为什么是正确的，我的理解（不知道对不对）是：
1 have improved sound的violin 和 best-sound的声音有区别；
2 对于专业的violinists而言，跟best-sound有区别的violin就是声音没它好的violin，因此就是比best-sound violin差的；
3 专业violinist是唯一可以评价音质的人。

而D是：现在不可能制造一个被专业violinist评价为have improved sound的violin

这里面的逻辑还是不清楚……
跪求解答……

-- by 会员 竹灵溪月 (2011/8/7 23:18:40)

What you listed as No. 2 is saying that "NONE of the new violins would be better than the current best-sound violin, to a professional violinist."

竹灵溪月

我好像知道我问题出在哪里了……

原文中的“ have improved violin” 和选项中的“ having improved violin” 的意思是指“需要提高音质的琴”和“提高过音质的琴”，是吗？
这样一来的话，D选项就是“不能造出被专家认为是提高了音质的（跟best一样）的琴” ……？


这个having 和 have在句子里的意思是不是这么理解的？？


不好意思，求再指点~~不胜感激……

abbylung

一个小提琴被制造目的是为了提高音质，这个小提琴听起来不同于音质最棒的已存在的小提琴。对专业小提琴家来说，一个小提琴听起来不同于音质最好的已存在的小提琴，这个小提琴听起来就不像一个小提琴，并且比音质最棒的已存在的小提琴更差。专业的小提琴家们是唯一的被接受的评判官属于这个音质属于小提琴。

也就是说被制造的小提琴对专业的小提琴家来说根本就不可能是好的小提琴。

D说，目前不可能去制造一个小提琴，专业的小提琴家将会评估这个小提琴是已经提高了音质的。因为专业的小提琴家根本就不会认同制造出来的小提琴。

大咕咕毛

abbylung 发表于 2020-3-19 20:59
一个小提琴被制造目的是为了提高音质，这个小提琴听起来不同于音质最棒的已存在的小提琴。对专业小提琴家来 ...

虽然很可能看不到，但还是想谢谢解答顺便你这个文章解释听起来好像我之前上课的老师