OG12-21 有一点不明白 求教大家～

gmgmwll

Neuroscientists, having amassed a wealth of knowledge over the past twenty years about the brain and its development from birth to adulthood, are now drawing solid conclusions about how the human brain grows and how babies acquire language.
A. Neuroscientists, having amassed a wealth of knowledge over the past twenty years about the brain and its development from birth to adulthood, are
B. Neuroscientists, having amassed a wealth of knowledge about the brain and its development from birth to adulthood over the past twenty years, and are
C. Neuroscientists amassing a wealth of knowledge about the brain and its development from birth to adulthood over the past twenty years, and are
D. Neuroscientists have amassed a wealth of knowledge over the past twenty years about the brain and its development from birth to adulthood,
E. Neuroscientists have amassed, over the past twenty years, a wealth of knowledge about the brain and its development from birth to adulthood,

答案是A   OG对D的解释为 the final descripor in the present tense, now drawing conclusion...does not fit the opening clause, which is in present-perfect tense(have amassed a wealth..) and seems to modifey adulthood.
为什么 doing 不能跟在have done 的后面呢， 各位大仙给解释一下呗  谢谢谢谢～～～

my8822180

doing 做定语肯定是不可能，但为什么不能做伴随结果呢。have done 是说他们过去二十年已经...，这个动作的结果是  ：现在得出...结论，不行吗

-- by 会员 gato (2011/9/9 6:35:07)

cd语法区有个帖子是在说明如何根据句意来解题的，我觉得从你的角度理解的话是不是可以这样看，就是说这个句子的重点是想说她们现在得出结论了，而不是想表达他们过去做了什么呢？做题的时候当然不是这么做的，只是说从你的角度理解，或许也可以这样想吧

gato

doing 做定语肯定是不可能，但为什么不能做伴随结果呢。have done 是说他们过去二十年已经...，这个动作的结果是  ：现在得出...结论，不行吗

justinfang

关于2楼hehe316的解释，我觉得D中的drawing 也可以作为结果解释啊，为什么你觉得不可以作为结果解释呢？

-- by 会员 chenzhen8752 (2011/8/1 11:37:48)

个人认为：drawing前面有个now，和前面句子的时间形成逻辑上的对比，所以最后一句now drawing。。。做伴随状语就不合适了。即使做定语也不合适吧。

justinfang

我有一点不明白，在解释D项
The final descriptor in present tense, now
drawing conclusions ... does not fit the
opening clause,
which is in present-perfect
tense (have amassed a wealth ...) and seems
to modify adulthood.
为什么是只修饰adulthood

-- by 会员 小鱼爱溪 (2011/8/1 13:01:55)

现在分词的伴随语-now drawing conclusions。。。。
按照意思理解不可能修饰现在完成时这个句子，所以语法上只能修饰adulthood，所以是错的

gmgmwll

关于2楼hehe316的解释，我觉得D中的drawing 也可以作为结果解释啊，为什么你觉得不可以作为结果解释呢？

-- by 会员 chenzhen8752 (2011/8/1 11:37:48)

当时弄懂了 现在有晕了。，顶一下，同问drawing为什么不能做结果呢？

小鱼爱溪

我有一点不明白，在解释D项
The final descriptor in present tense, now
drawing conclusions ... does not fit the
opening clause,
which is in present-perfect
tense (have amassed a wealth ...) and seems
to modify adulthood.
为什么是只修饰adulthood

chenzhen8752

关于2楼hehe316的解释，我觉得D中的drawing 也可以作为结果解释啊，为什么你觉得不可以作为结果解释呢？

gmgmwll

谢谢 这样就明白了~

hehe316

这里的doing只有两种用法，表示伴随或者结果。表伴随的话，不能用一个正在进行的动作表示一个已经完成的动作。。。
表结果的话，从逻辑上来看，drawing solid conclusions并不是 amassed a wealth of knowledge 的结果。