指代的问题！！！！！！！急！！！

kingstorm666

代词到底是服从就近指代原则还是逻辑原则呀。。。。晕。。。。题中怎么判断。。。

Whereas the honeybee’s stinger is heavily barbed and cannot be retracted from the skin, because the yellow jacket has a comparatively smooth stinger, it is therefore able to be pulled out and used again.

A. because the yellow jacket has a comparatively smooth stinger, it is therefore able to be pulled out and used

B. the comparative smoothness of the yellow jacket’s stinger allows them to pull it out and then can therefore use it

C. the yellow jacket’s stinger is comparatively smooth, and can therefore be pulled out and used

D. in comparison, the yellow jacket’s stinger is smooth, and thus able to be pulled out and used

E. in comparison, the yellow jacket has a smooth stinger, thus allowing it to be pulled out and used

中E里的it到底对吗。。。。晕
是就近还是逻辑来判断。。。NN

zxkingsey

我觉得是对的，it就是指代s
因为从逻辑上来说不可能是y有s，使得y自己被pulled out

bennywang2usa

以逻辑原则为主，GMAT出现代词必为考点！要格外小心！

gtr

代词到底是服从就近指代原则还是逻辑原则呀。。。。晕。。。。题中怎么判断。。。

Whereas the honeybee’s stinger is heavily barbed and cannot be retracted from the skin, because the yellow jacket has a comparatively smooth stinger, it is therefore able to be pulled out and used again.

A. because the yellow jacket has a comparatively smooth stinger, it is therefore able to be pulled out and used

B. the comparative smoothness of the yellow jacket’s stinger allows them to pull it out and then can therefore use it

C. the yellow jacket’s stinger is comparatively smooth, and can therefore be pulled out and used

D. in comparison, the yellow jacket’s stinger is smooth, and thus able to be pulled out and used

E. in comparison, the yellow jacket has a smooth stinger, thus allowing it to be pulled out and used

中E里的it到底对吗。。。。晕
是就近还是逻辑来判断。。。NN

-- by 会员 kingstorm666 (2010/2/4 23:29:11)

E 肯定不对啊，都不对称


这句话前面说 Whereas the honeybee’s stinger，你一定要后面对称一个stinger，而不是蜜蜂啊


只能 C D里面找正确的答案


D 一个 able to 不带助动词裸奔，肯定错啊，就 C 正确了

tomorrow1992

http://forum.chasedream.com/GMAT_SC/thread-404535-1.html
这是讨论帖~