ChaseDream

标题: Helr GMAT题库 周周练 Helr-CR-002 (答案和解析已放出) [打印本页]
作者: GMAT    时间: 2012-7-10 00:22
标题: Helr GMAT题库 周周练 Helr-CR-002 (答案和解析已放出)

欢迎大家以如下方式参与Helr GMAT题库周周练活动：

Helr-CR-002

Shelbyville is a place of tourist attraction. In Shelbyville’s two most famous sight spots, one is located in the east part of the city and the other one is in the west. The way that links the west part and east part of Shelbyville is a one-way road, so all the tourists who travel in Shelbyville always went from west sight spots to east sight spots. Since a great many tourists just want to go to the east sight spot, Shelbyville’s travel agency propose to organize tour groups that only travel to the east sight spot to meet the desire of those tourists. 

Which of the following, if true, most strongly supports the claim that the proposal, if carried out, will have the announced effect?

A. Tourists who just want to go to east sight spot will not force their tour group to travel to the west sight spot after travelling to the east sight spot.
B. The cost of travelling to east sight spot only will not exceed that of travelling both to the east and to the west.
C. Almost all famous local attractions are scattered along the highway to the east part of Shelbyville, these are what attracts the tourists most.
D. Most of the tourists who want to go to east sight spot are adolescents, who are the most important consumer groups in Shelbyville.
E. In east part of Shelbyville, a large discount shopping mall, which can attract tourists from other cities to the mall, will be built in 2 years.

作者: Helr    时间: 2012-7-10 00:50
标题: Argument Evaluation:

Situation： Shelbyville 是一个旅游胜地，这座城市分为东西两边。连接东部和西部的道路是一条单行线，所以大家现在只能先到西边后到东边。现在因为有大量游客只想去东边旅游，所以Shelbyville的旅游部门决定组织就去东边的旅行线路

Reasoning： Which of the following, if true, most strongly supports the claim that the proposal, if carried out, will have the announced effect? 这个题目的结论是：“Shelbyville’s travel agency propose to organize tour groups that only travel to the east sight spot to meet the desire of those tourists. ”这个计划如果能满足只想去东边旅客，就必须能保证这些去了东边旅行旅客不再想去西边，否则推出一个只到东边的旅行线路就反而会让情况变的更加复杂（因为只有从西边到东边的单行线）。也就是说，如果游客去了东边后会不会改变主意又想去西边的话，这个计划就可以达成效果。

-----

A. 正确。这个选项加强了这个计划能达成想要的效果。如果大家在游览过东边后，不会强迫旅行社带他们再去西边的话，那么这个方案就可以缓解现在有大量游客只想去东边的问题。

B. 只去东边和东西边都去的价格是否相同与这个计划是否有效无关。

C. 这个选项说明了为什么大部分游客只想去东边旅行，属于对于前提的解释。

D. 想去的东边的游客是什么类型的与是否要创造只有东边的旅行线路无关。

E. 解释两年后东边可以更加吸引游客对于方案的形成没有帮助

作者: ychen34    时间: 2012-7-11 07:46
参与讨论
个人觉得答案应该选A  也不知道对不对

A  正确
B cost 无关选项 文中没提到成本的问题
C 无关选项
D 感觉不对 D选项里面说的是who want go to east spot 而题目说的是 just want to go to east spot 先去西边再去东边不影响参观east spot啊
E shopping mall 也是无关选项
作者: babybearmm    时间: 2012-7-11 07:58
欢迎大家以如下方式参与Helr GMAT题库周周练活动：
Helr-CR-002
Shelbyville is a place of tourist attraction. In Shelbyville’s two most famous sight spots, one is located in the east part of the city and the other one is in the west. The way that links the west part and east part of Shelbyville is a one-way road, so all the tourists who travel in Shelbyville always went from west sight spots to east sight spots. Since a great many tourists just want to go to the east sight spot, Shelbyville’s travel agency propose to organize tour groups that only travel to the east sight spot to meet the desire of those tourists.  
Which of the following, if true, most strongly supports the claim that the proposal, if carried out, will have the announced effect?
A. Tourists who just want to go to east sight spot will not force their tour group to travel to the west sight spot after travelling to the east sight spot.
B. The cost of travelling to east sight spot only will not exceed that of travelling both to the east and to the west.
C. Almost all famous local attractions are scattered along the highway to the east part of Shelbyville, these are what attracts the tourists most.
D. Most of the tourists who want to go to east sight spot are adolescents, who are the most important consumer groups in Shelbyville.
E. In east part of Shelbyville, a large discount shopping mall, which can attract tourists from other cities to the mall, will be built in 2 years.
-- by 会员 GMAT (2012/7/10 0:22:16)




参与讨论
选A


Question: ... most strongly supports the claim that the proposal, if carried out, will have the announced effect
What's the announced effect? In other words, what's the purpose (goal) of this proposal?


Shelbyville’s travel agency propose to organize tour groups that only travel to the east sight spot to meet the desire of those tourists
Here's the announced effect: "to meet the desire of those tourists"
those tourists = "a great many tourists" who "just want to go to the east sight spot"


Therefore, all we care is their desire - "just want to ..."
Other things such as attractions along the highway (C) and shopping center (E) are out-of-scope, let alone considerations such as costs (B) or the already-established necessity of serving those tourists (D).  


Choice (A) is perfectly written in a way that focuses on the desire of those tourists. We know that those tourists just want to go to the East sight, but do they have additional desire? (A) addresses this issue.
作者: sheryter    时间: 2012-7-11 08:52
A啦，其他都无关选项
作者: HerringtonD    时间: 2012-7-11 09:19
支持baby

Travelling cost in (B) is orthogonal to the announcement. Attraction along highway(C), if true, would only weaken the proposal. Consumers' predilection(D) does nothing with tourists' behavior. E will enhance the validity of this proposal, but it is not the strongest since shopping center is not the critical issue in this proposal.

A clearly rules out other possibility that the tourists will want to visit west sight afterward.
作者: 嘟啦嘟比yoyo    时间: 2012-7-11 12:13
参与讨论：
我选A

原文结论是Since a great many tourists just want to go to the east sight spot, Shelbyville’s travel agency propose to organize tour groups that only travel to the east sight spot to meet the desire of those tourists.  
需要注意的一个是管理tour groups，另一个是only。
A选项中说去东边玩的旅客在参观结束后不会想再去西边了，也就说明这个only去东边的tour group正好满足了这部分游客的需求。
B、C、D、E都是无关选项
作者: kevinlaci    时间: 2012-7-11 14:32
标题: 参与讨论
我认为答案为A。
A选项最为直接相关需要参观的地点。
作者: 草莓葡萄    时间: 2012-7-11 19:45
我觉得是B,
A选项， 并不能让结论更有道理吧。因为逛完东边的不想再去西边不等于逛完西边之后再去东边然后不想再回西边吧。
相比B选项，如果不会让直接逛东边的花更多的钱，那只想逛东边的就直接去东边逛了， 这个是support吧
作者: emmarice    时间: 2012-7-13 10:58
参与讨论
A

bcde都无关吧
作者: zhengjiahan    时间: 2012-7-13 17:07
A  
作者: Johnsonjz    时间: 2012-7-13 17:35
参与讨论
个人认为是B
原文的大致意思是S有东西两个景点，有一条单行道连接，因此游客要想游览两个景点的话就必须从西边的过路到东边。而由于大部分的游客都只想去东边的景点，因此建议组一个只去东边的团。（很明显，答案就是要说明该方案可行）

而B如果成立，也就是说改变游览方案不会产生额外的费用，即两个方案的效果一样，而大多数的tourists 只想去一个景点，那么原文的方案就是可行的。

反之，如果对B取非，也就是说原文提议的旅游方案会产生比原来多的额外费用，那么这无疑是该方案的一个明显的漏洞。在这样的情况下，就不能确保原方案一定可行。
作者: dorothyyy    时间: 2012-7-14 09:54
标题: 参与讨论
我觉得选B。

CDE都有明显的问题。在A和B之间纠结了一会儿。
但是原题说的是大家本来是因为从West到East是One-way Road，所以哪怕绝大部分人只想去E也只好从W去E，地方为了方便他们才开通了只去E的团。

A说这样大家去玩E就不会再去W
B说直接去E的价钱不会超过从W去E。

我觉得B是直接相关，支持了这个措施会成功（如果直接去E更贵，大家会处于经济考虑仍然选择从W去E，就达不到效果了。）
作者: 5wzy5418    时间: 2012-7-14 12:56
支持baby
作者: Jessica0320    时间: 2012-7-15 21:35
A

The annouced effect is “meet the desire of those tourists”.  So the point relevent to "the desire of tourists" could best support the claim of the proposal.
作者: jsmart    时间: 2012-7-16 17:14
觉得是A
作者: xiaoyongnao    时间: 2012-7-16 18:58
A不對
作者: lixuekai2001    时间: 2012-7-17 00:06
参与讨论
选B

Type of the question: Strengthen

Conclusion: Shelbyville’s travel agency propose to organize tour groups that only travel to the east sight spot to meet the desire of those tourists who just want to go to the east sight spot.

A: the target clients are the kind who "just want to go to the east sight spot". Logically, they won't require travelling to the west spot as both the tour agency and the clients side should be aware of the previous defined route: only go to the east part.

B: the cost of going to the east only won't exceed that of going the west plus the east. It strengths the agency proposal of the new tourism route. Because the target clients are bearing the wasting of money (the cost to the west+the east > the cost to the east only)and the wasting of their time(travel to the west firstly before to their favorite east sight spot). If the agency provide the new "only to the east"tourism route and moreover the cost is no higher than before, the tourists will like the plan and the agency proposal would be successful.
作者: MINOZ芸    时间: 2012-7-17 21:20
选A，最直接相关
作者: romn    时间: 2012-7-20 19:09
在A 和B  选项中纠结...还是认为选B  ------
主要是文中 " will have the announced effect" ，这是站在旅行社的角度， 以广告口吻来说的。 那么显然对于游客吸引力的话，价格肯定是关键因素。所以B 选项的"The cost ....will not exceed...  "命中。
作者: xn8510    时间: 2012-7-26 13:22
我觉得是B~~
作者: hpnew07    时间: 2012-8-2 17:05
参与讨论

A

其他都与proposal无关
作者: healthjiang    时间: 2012-8-7 00:05
参与讨论
我选D
原文：S地东、西两景点，游客只能通过单行道由西到东。但因为大部分游客只想去东，因此提议组团去东满足那些游客的需求。

A选项，那些想去东的游客不会强迫团去西。尽管很多人选A，但我没看出A从逻辑上任何支持结论的。强迫或不强迫又怎么样呢？并不支持推理呀。
B选项，只去东的费用不会更高。这个还有点考虑，毕竟如果只去一个地方更贵的话大家还不如去两个地方。但原文客户的需求不在钱上，因此非支持。
C选项，大部分美景都在沿途。这个明显削弱，因为如果这样的话大家都要从西到东沿途欣赏风景。
D选项，大部分只想去东的都是年轻人，而这些人正是S最主要的顾客。支持原文，既然有需求的顾客很集中，又是主要顾客，当然要尽量满足他们的需求。
E选项，在东两年后会开个大折扣店。首先折扣店无关，其次即使开店会吸引客户，但只去东和由西到东最终都能去店，不支持只去东的逻辑。
作者: louisehu    时间: 2012-8-14 17:00
选A，以为如果A不是的话，也就是都会让tourist group重新再走一遍的话，那么就达不到目的了，与原文的结论中的only也矛盾。
作者: srafcatt    时间: 2012-10-8 13:43
参与讨论
Helr-CR-002
Shelbyville is a place of tourist attraction. In Shelbyville’s two most famous sight spots, one is located in the east part of the city and the other one is in the west. The way that links the west part and east part of Shelbyville is a one-way road, so all the tourists who travel in Shelbyville always went from west sight spots to east sight spots. Since a great many tourists just want to go to the east sight spot, Shelbyville’s travel agency propose to organize tour groups that only travel to the east sight spot to meet the desire of those tourists.  
Which of the following, if true, most strongly supports the claim that the proposal, if carried out, will have the announced effect?
A. Tourists who just want to go to east sight spot will not force their tour group to travel to the west sight spot after travelling to the east sight spot.
B. The cost of travelling to east sight spot only will not exceed that of travelling both to the east and to the west.
C. Almost all famous local attractions are scattered along the highway to the east part of Shelbyville, these are what attracts the tourists most.
D. Most of the tourists who want to go to east sight spot are adolescents, who are the most important consumer groups in Shelbyville.
E. In east part of Shelbyville, a large discount shopping mall, which can attract tourists from other cities to the mall, will be built in 2 years.
reasoning chain:
because:some tourist just want to go to the eastside spot
so:agency set up a tour to meet their need.
choice：C
A the plan will be excecute smoothly
B the plan is not surprisingly expensive
C it is a good choice to have a trip this way for consumers
D it has profits for companies.
E irrelevant
作者: srafcatt    时间: 2012-10-8 13:53
支持不是解释，因此只是解释（就像C 选项）是不行的
作者: thumark    时间: 2013-1-27 11:29
呵呵呵呵呵
作者: 旺财财    时间: 2014-9-8 23:18
看过，谢谢herl前辈



欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3