对一道争论题的看法--大全section-A11

看了很多nn的讨论，试着总结一下，并说一下我的看法，希望大家指正。

11.   Marketing researchers have found that, because many residents of the Southeast do not share the same ethnic heritage as Northeasterners, the two varieties of commercially prepared coleslaw most popular in New York City and Boston are virtually ignored by consumers in Richmond and Raleigh.b

(A) because many residents of the Southeast do not share the same ethnic heritage as

(B) because many residents of the Southeast do not share the same ethnic heritage with

(C) because many residents of the Southeast do not have the same ethnic heritage as

(D) due to many residents of the Southeast not sharing the same ethnic heritage with（C）

(E) whereas many residents of the Southeast do not share the same ethnic heritage as

答案争论在b和C上

1．Ogram说C选项把ethnic heritage 同Northeasterners 放在一起作比较，范了严重错误（我也认为若要比较正确，应该在as后面补出DO。）另外，在GMAT语法中，have在表示“拥有”的意思时，往往是接具体名词，如have a book, have a car等等，而不接heritage之类的抽象名词

B选项是可以接受的

share 至少有两种用法，一种是X and Y share sth.,另一种是X share sth. with Y.

B选项用的是后一种用法。same 放在这里只是起强调作用，跟the same as 的固定搭配无关

为什么我们提到same 的时候，非要把它跟as扯在一起呢？好像same离了as 就活不成了。国内的英文教育真是误人不浅啊

2．braveMBA的个人观点：
A从意思的角度有不合理之处，原句想表达的意思是“因为SE没有象NE一样的民族传统，所以....”。而A使用了SHARE出现了意思上的问题，是SE自己分享这个传统呢？还是同NE共享一个传统呢？HAVE，没有这个问题，表明了各自具备的传统。
觉得这个题，意思太细微，错就错了，完全是感觉。

我不同意这个观点，

share 在oxford的解释中有have sth in common 的意思，并举例为share sb’s belief ，faith ，optimism，et 与某人拥有共同的信仰，信念，乐观态度

3有人认为.b错是因为share 和same 同意重复。ets的原则。好像og上有

但是确有share the same的用法呀。有没有哪个nn可以就share 和same 同意重复。ets的原则。好像og上有举下例呀。

Choice C is incorrect. The verb is missing.

If the same ... as ... has to be used, it should be written as something like,

because many residents of the Southeast do not have the same ethnic heritage as Northeasterners do

There is nothing wrong with "share the same thing with someone".

"share the same" is redundant.the same......as is idiomatic.so anwer c must be right.

楼主，我不这样认为。看到的很多国外报刊就这样用。如果说这是ets的perfer还可以考虑。

请教楼主，你这么说的例子或是出处在哪里？又怎么解释我在1点中给出的比较错的错误？

我同意2楼