ChaseDream

标题: Help! 什么时候用"In which' and 什么时候用"When"?? [打印本页]

作者: Alpha4Dream 时间: 2014-10-2 10:56
标题: Help! 什么时候用"In which' and 什么时候用"When"??
After I searched this question in CD for a hour, I still cannot find the answer... TT... (in school computer lab so I cannot type Chinese..Sorry)

In OG 13 35, "when" is the correct pronoun for "time".
In og13 72, "when" and "in which" can be used interchangeably to modify "an age".
Also, I saw someone said "以前上XDF的时老师讲说 age用in which 修饰； time 具体年代用when修饰"

Could someone tells me the differences between these "in which" and "when"? Thanks!

作者: lainemai 时间: 2014-10-2 22:24
嗯，两个是可以对调的，Manhattan语法第六章讲过一句话：The pronoun when can be used to modify a noun event or time, such as period, age,1987,or decade.In these circumstances, you can also use in which instead of when.

open to discussion.

作者: Alpha4Dream 时间: 2014-10-3 02:29

lainemai 发表于 2014-10-2 22:24
嗯，两个是可以对调的，Manhattan语法第六章讲过一句话：The pronoun when can be used to modify a noun e ...

However, in OG 13 35, the author says "when" is the proper modifier for "a time" in that case....
是因为 the only exception is "a time"?
还是因为结合语义 there's an "at" used before "a time" 所以不用 "in" ?

I selected D at the first place because of the same reason you mentioned above.. TT

作者: lainemai 时间: 2014-10-3 15:15
in which的前提本身是修饰时间time的，但是亲你看到了前面time有个介词at,又是at a time又是in a time那这句话到底想要说什么，把in a time带进去，那in a time也不是什么惯用短语丫亲......所以结合GMAC原则，肯定是优先选when的呀，而且要是我来选这道题，第一眼看到in which我也会先排除，因为不管怎样，when总是比in which来得要好。~~~
open to discussion

欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/)