ChaseDream

标题: [SC悬赏令] 同学转给我的我也做错了求大神讲解 [打印本页]

作者: jessiejcjsjz    时间: 2014-9-15 11:47
标题: [SC悬赏令] 同学转给我的我也做错了求大神讲解
1. A thoroughly frightened child was seen by her covering in the corner of the room. (全句下划线)
A.  A thoroughly frightened child was seen by her covering in the corner of the room.
B. Cowering in the corner of the room, a thoroughly frightened child was seen by her.
C. She saw, cowering in the corner of the room, a thoroughly frightened child.
D. A thoroughly frightened child, cowering in the corner of the room, was seen by her.
E. She saw a thoroughly frightened child who was cowering in the corner of the room.

C
作者: bryant92    时间: 2014-9-15 13:21
这个题目好奇怪,she都没有指代对象

Anyway, 我觉得应该选E吧。句意是她看见了一个小孩蜷缩在角落

没有一个合适的理由一定要用被动形式。
A:covering in the corner of the room像是修饰her的,有歧义;被动形式不好
B:没有语法错误,消除了A的歧义,但仍是被动形式,不好
C:cowering in the corner of the room变成了修饰she, 或者说解释前面clause的动作,不是原句intended meaning
D:消除了C句中的错误,cowering修饰了child,但仍是被动形式
E是没有歧义的,且为主动形式

cowering in the corner of the room应该是修饰a thoroughly frightened child的吧
作者: jessiejcjsjz    时间: 2014-9-15 15:13
bryant92 发表于 2014-9-15 13:21
这个题目好奇怪,she都没有指代对象

Anyway, 我觉得应该选E吧。句意是她看见了一个小孩蜷缩在角落

哎呀 我们也觉得应该是E ,但是答案是C 感觉这样的用法很奇怪,晚点我去问下我同学到底是哪本书上来的 多谢你的详细分析!
作者: bryant92    时间: 2014-9-15 20:32
jessiejcjsjz 发表于 2014-9-15 15:13
哎呀 我们也觉得应该是E ,但是答案是C 感觉这样的用法很奇怪,晚点我去问下我同学到底是哪本书上来的 多 ...

如果是C的话,语法上也对的。意思就是“她蜷缩在角落里,看到了一个害怕的小孩”,但感觉也可以理解成“她看见了一个蜷缩在角落里的小孩”;

如果根据划线部分理解,似乎还真有可能intended meaning是“一个害怕的小孩被蜷缩在角落里的她看到”,这样的话还真有可能选C...




欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3