标题: CR OG13的第111题关于正确答案A的疑问 [打印本页] 作者: zcdzheng 时间: 2013-5-12 18:09 标题: CR OG13的第111题关于正确答案A的疑问 111. Springfield Fire Commissioner: The vastmajority offalse fire alarms are prank calls made anonymously from fire
alarm boxes on street corners. Sincevirtually everyone has access to a privatetelephone, these alarm boxes
have outlived their usefulness.Therefore, wepropose to remove the boxes. Removing the boxes will reduce the
number of prank calls withouthampering people's ability to report a fire.
Which of the following, iftrue, most strongly supports the claimthat the proposal, ifcarried out, will havethe
announced effect?
(A)
Thefire department traces all alarm calls madefrom private telephones and records wherethey
came from.
(B)
Maintaining the fire alarm boxes costs Springfield approximately $5 million annually.
(C)
Atelephone call can provide the fire department withmore information about the nature and size of a fire
than can an alarm placed from an alarm box.
(D)
Respondingto false alarms significantly reduces the firedepartment's capacity for responding to fires.
(E)
On anygivenday,a significant percentage ofthe public telephones inSpringfield are out of service.
这个正确答案是A
但是我觉得这个答案有问题。
问题问的是选项哪一个最能证明：如果这个proposal被执行，会产生宣称的效果。
这个proposal就是remove the boxes。
而宣称的效果有两个：减少虚假报警和不妨碍人们报警的能力。
虽然A答案确实可以减少虚假报警，但是A答案和这个proposal没有关系，它不能使proposal产生宣称的效果。
所以我觉得A答案逻辑也有问题。
不过因为其他四个其实更不合适，A孬好对结论有作用，所以。。。。
童鞋，这里是语法专区也
