ChaseDream

标题: 弱弱的我又来问了，一道谓语单复数的SC [打印本页]

---

作者: jakepoineer    时间: 2013-3-5 08:15
标题: 弱弱的我又来问了，一道谓语单复数的SC
At an orientation meeting, the travelers were told that a visa, a landing card, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever would be needed by each of them.

• A a visa, a landing card, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever would be needed by each of them
  
• B they would need a visa, a landing card, and evidence of their being inoculated against typhoid fever
  
• C they would need evidence of being inoculated against typhoid fever and a visa and landing card
  
• D they would each need a visa, a landing card, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever
  
• E they would need visas, landing cards, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever for each of them
  
  这道题答案是D
  我选的是E，E错在哪？
  还有就是each的单复数如何确定？each of+N后面的谓语单复数如何确定？D这里的each后面为什么不是needs？
  

---

作者: 露比Alice    时间: 2013-3-5 09:33
我的分析
a 选项 句子主语在宾语从句中做主语，用主动语态比较好 个人觉得这个句子强调need的发出者 所以被动罗嗦。
b 选项of+being结构也wordy
c 改变句意 typhoid fever and a visa and landing card 三者平行
d 和e的差别在于 1.they would each need 和 they would need 前者后面跟着的名词应该是单数，后者后面跟着的名词应该是复数 而 e中evidences没有用复数。2.for each of them放在最后面 them有指代歧义，因为前面有好几个复数名词可以指代。而且for放在后面怪怪的，they would need for each of them 明显不如 they would each need表达简洁。

---

作者: 露比Alice    时间: 2013-3-5 09:33
对了
b they would need后面的名词应该是用复数

---

作者: jakepoineer    时间: 2013-3-5 10:14

我的分析
a 选项 句子主语在宾语从句中做主语，用主动语态比较好 个人觉得这个句子强调need的发出者 所以被动罗嗦。
b 选项of+being结构也wordy
c 改变句意 typhoid fever and a visa and landing card 三者平行
d 和e的差别在于 1.they would each need 和 they would need 前者后面跟着的名词应该是单数，后者后面跟着的名词应该是复数 而 e中evidences没有用复数。2.for each of them放在最后面 them有指代歧义，因为前面有好几个复数名词可以指代。而且for放在后面怪怪的，they would need for each of them 明显不如 they would each need表达简洁。

-- by 会员 露比Alice (2013/3/5 9:33:10)

好的，但是each单复数使用情况能否给我指点一下，有些模糊

---

作者: kiwifoodtown    时间: 2013-3-5 10:50

我的分析
a 选项 句子主语在宾语从句中做主语，用主动语态比较好 个人觉得这个句子强调need的发出者 所以被动罗嗦。
b 选项of+being结构也wordy
c 改变句意 typhoid fever and a visa and landing card 三者平行
d 和e的差别在于 1.they would each need 和 they would need 前者后面跟着的名词应该是单数，后者后面跟着的名词应该是复数 而 e中evidences没有用复数。2.for each of them放在最后面 them有指代歧义，因为前面有好几个复数名词可以指代。而且for放在后面怪怪的，they would need for each of them 明显不如 they would each need表达简洁。

-- by 会员 露比Alice (2013/3/5 9:33:10)

好的，但是each单复数使用情况能否给我指点一下，有些模糊

-- by 会员 jakepoineer (2013/3/5 10:14:36)

each 作主语一定用单数，比如 each of things , 但D 选项是 they作主语。

---

作者: jakepoineer    时间: 2013-3-5 12:51

我的分析
a 选项 句子主语在宾语从句中做主语，用主动语态比较好 个人觉得这个句子强调need的发出者 所以被动罗嗦。
b 选项of+being结构也wordy
c 改变句意 typhoid fever and a visa and landing card 三者平行
d 和e的差别在于 1.they would each need 和 they would need 前者后面跟着的名词应该是单数，后者后面跟着的名词应该是复数 而 e中evidences没有用复数。2.for each of them放在最后面 them有指代歧义，因为前面有好几个复数名词可以指代。而且for放在后面怪怪的，they would need for each of them 明显不如 they would each need表达简洁。

-- by 会员 露比Alice (2013/3/5 9:33:10)

好的，但是each单复数使用情况能否给我指点一下，有些模糊

-- by 会员 jakepoineer (2013/3/5 10:14:36)

each 作主语一定用单数，比如 each of things , 但D 选项是 they作主语。

-- by 会员 kiwifoodtown (2013/3/5 10:50:59)

原来如此，糊涂了，thx

---

作者: huluwaxibei    时间: 2013-8-6 19:57
E选项 前面已经有they了 后面还加个for each of them，难道不是多余么？？？我是这么分析的 不知道对不对哈

---

欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/)

Powered by Discuz! X3.3