ChaseDream

标题: 来了一道猪猪牛牛的比较题 [打印本页]

作者: 橙色的鱼 时间: 2012-4-9 21:40
标题: 来了一道猪猪牛牛的比较题
prep笔记上面的一个句子，惊鸿一瞥滴让我森森的觉得有点问题，在此请各位帮忙解答
the farm has more than twice as many cows as it has pigs.我觉得这里it has是多余了，删掉也不会影响意思，就直接当做是cow and pig的比较而不是has cow 和 has pigs的比较。。

作者: ttturtlett 时间: 2012-4-9 23:18
我想是has cows和has pigs 比較吧。

the farm has more than twice as many cows as pigs.

可能是 the farm has more than twice as many cows as it has pigs ,
但也可能是 the farm has more than twice as many cows as pigs have cows.

作者: 橙色的鱼 时间: 2012-4-10 08:28
对哈，童鞋分析得好精准。。比较的省略一直是一根刺，你说这里其实省略了应该也不会有歧义吧毕竟pig是不可能has cow的。

作者: ttturtlett 时间: 2012-4-11 14:47
看看這貼子，在最下面我有寫一篇解釋，看完會你的比較省略會有幫助的
http://forum.chasedream.com/GMAT_Math/thread-699916-1-1.html

作者: 橙色的鱼 时间: 2012-4-12 12:30
谢啦~~特别是新旧观点那个看法很独到

作者: leonnong 时间: 2012-5-7 19:37

prep笔记上面的一个句子，惊鸿一瞥滴让我森森的觉得有点问题，在此请各位帮忙解答
the farm has more than twice as many cows as it has pigs.我觉得这里it has是多余了，删掉也不会影响意思，就直接当做是cow and pig的比较而不是has cow 和 has pigs的比较。。

-- by 会员橙色的鱼 (2012/4/9 21:40:26)

我想问题下这个句子是出自哪里的呢？我觉得楼主说得有道理！
我觉得这个句子是不对的呀~因为这句话的意思是farm里的cow是pig的两倍，比较的是cow和pig的数量. 但是如果你说as it has pigs就感觉是比较has pigs。就不符合逻辑了！也希望NN讨论一下！
可以参考一下http://www.manhattangmat.com/forums/fossil-fuels-t2119.html
(a) I have 10 times as many MP3s as my father. OK
(b) I have 10 times as many MP3s as was the case before I bought a computer. Awkward but OK.
(c) I have 10 times as many MP3s as I had MP3s before I bought a computer. BAD. Wrong. Why is (c) so bad? You are comparing the number of MP3s (I now have 10 times as many). By repeating the noun (MP3s) and verb (had), it sounds like you are saying that what is 10 x is greater is not the number of MP3s but having the MP3s. It doesn't make sense. In Stacy's explanation, the energy is implied, but restating it (or replacing it with 'it') really confuses the sentence, just as my example in (c) is really confusing.

作者: qiuyun2011 时间: 2012-5-7 20:44

看看這貼子，在最下面我有寫一篇解釋，看完會你的比較省略會有幫助的
http://forum.chasedream.com/GMAT_Math/thread-699916-1-1.html

-- by 会员 ttturtlett (2012/4/11 14:47:50)

我决的这个帖子里的题跟楼主贴的是不一样的啊
楼主的这个题是两个名词归属的比较，这个帖子里的题是两个动作的比较
所以觉得楼主去掉has的想法是正确的，因为这个题不存在归属不明的情况啊，如果不省略的话倒是不对的了

欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/)