ChaseDream

标题: 请教CR JJ 17题目 [打印本页]

作者: mathfin9 时间: 2004-8-28 00:18
标题: 请教CR JJ 17题目

17. Dave: water-jet boats are safe, because they owned by 35% people who water jet, and only 10% of the insurance claims is associated with such boats.

Adam: it is not true since these boats are cheap, usually people do not insure them.

Which of the following is the best argument for Dave to counter Adam’s argument?

the author: chose "because when such boats involved in an accident, the other boats are always more expensive, thus the owners of these boats will always file for claims for insurance

弱人弱问，谁能把楼主选的这个答案给解释一下

我觉得给的这个答案是支持ADAM的，而不是DAVE反对ADAM的

请牛人确认

作者: COOLLESS 时间: 2004-8-28 00:37
我觉得也有问题。如果 adam said: it it not true since thoese boats are cheap, usually people donont claim after accident. 就还能理解。但是答案中的file for claims 和 whether insure the boat 没有联系呀。

作者: mathfin9 时间: 2004-8-28 00:50

dave 认为WJboat 安全，证据是claim 中关于这种WJBOAT很少

adam观点是,boat不安全，claim中WJ少的原因是，因为WJ便宜，大家不买保险

DAVE说什么才能支持他原来的结论呢

前人给的答案是：因为事故发生的另外一方的BOAT比较贵，所以另外一方会申请赔偿；言下意思是，CLAIM的数量《WJ的事故发生率；也就是WJ未必安全

所以我认为答案给的是支持ADAM

欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/)