大家一起
。19. Similar to rising interest rates, consumer and producer prices have been rising.
(A) Similar to rising interest rates, consumer and producer prices have been rising.
(B) Consumer and producer prices have been rising, as have interest rates.
(C) As interest rates are rising, so have consumer and producer prices.
(D) Consumer and producer prices have been rising, like interest rates do.（B）
(E) Consumer and producer prices, as interest rates, have been rising.
不明白了，C错在哪？B中的as have interest rates. 倒装可以吗？谢谢！
C: "As interest rates are rising," 显然做壮语, 那么些 so have... 里的so就不知所云. 其次我认为..., so have...句式里前后句两者时态应一致(有点不确定,召唤NN)
NN怎么不搭理人啊!!!
25. Like many self-taught artists, Perle Hessing did not begin to paint until she was well into middle age.
(A) Like
(B) As have
(C) Just as with
(D) Just like（A）
(E) As did
搞不懂首楼的19题，是受这道题的影响，这题为什么不选E呢，看到以前有NN说是As dids倒装不好。那么回过来看上面的19题的B选项为什么用as have...呢？
11-19, C的As....,so...结构没有问题。问题是2个分句时态不一致，语义上不如B符合逻辑。同时，语法结构上，B的2个分句时态一致，可以清晰的判明省略了been risen；而C则不知道省了been rising还是risen。
25，E的意思反了。E的as前置，需要As....,so...结构。不过“As did”倒装可能是可以的。
谢谢tianwan!
不过有一点不太明白：“E的as前置，需要As....,so...结构。” 难道不可以说：As A do, B do? B前一定要加so 吗？谢谢！
谢谢！Tianwan.
不好意思，les， 我这几天忙着搬家，上网的时间少，所以刚刚看到你的短信
偶的感觉是As A do, （so）B do有so没so都是对的，大全里都有采用这两个表达方式的正确选项
关于19题C的问题，我个人认为是时态不同不能随意省略的问题，前面是进行时are rising,所以后面如果非要采用完成时就必须把动词形式写全，相应的例子我曾经做过笔记，不过今天是在外面上网，等我找到了贴上来。
关于25，E我觉得不是as did 不能倒装，而是肯定和否定的比较，不合逻辑：那些self-taught artists到底是也是很晚才开始创作还是相反，很早就开始创作了？
open to discussion.
19. Similar to rising interest rates, consumer and producer prices have been rising
(B) Consumer and producer prices have been rising, as have interest rates.
(C) As interest rates are rising, so have consumer and producer prices.
C错在哪？B中的as have interest rates. 倒装可以吗？谢谢！
c错在时态不一致， 而且我觉得前后语序的改变，导致句子重心的改变。似乎as have interest rate...在这里倒装没有错。
25. Like many self-taught artists, Perle Hessing did not begin to paint until she was well into middle age.
(A) Like
(B) As have
(C) Just as with
(D) Just like（A）
(E) As did
搞不懂首楼的19题，是受这道题的影响，这题为什么不选E呢，看到以前有NN说是As dids倒装不好。那么回过来看上面的19题的B选项为什么用as have...呢？
25题目中，我觉得有个问题是，选as 还是like是看后面是否跟句子。ets得简洁原则，应该是能用简洁表达的，就不用累赘的句子。除非，是有明显的错误。
我和其他的xdjm不大一样的是，我通常有点靠语感，也是一个双刃剑。不知道自己说清楚了没有。
1在正式或文学体文件中as引导的方式从句也通常主谓倒装
例如He believed, as did all his family, that the king was their supreme lord.
这也说倒装也成 不倒装也成
2 题25是OG91 说到
Choices B and E, which replace A’s prepositional phrase with clauses introduced by as, use auxiliary verbs that cannot properly be completed by any part of the verb phrase in the main clause: neither have... did not begin nor did... did not begin is logically or grammatically sound.
说明AS这样用 逻辑上不对应 语法上也不对应
3T19C主要是时态不对应
谢谢大家的回复！！！
marie mm 原来在搬家啊？！难怪好久不见。
大热天搬家真是辛苦！
大家一起。
看了大家的解释，同时偶自己在大全里找了一些例子，确认了一点：“as引导的方式从句也通常主谓倒装”－引用paopao的话。
偶找到的大全里的例子有：885-11-19和885-13-22。
2 题25是OG91 说到
Choices B and E, which replace A’s prepositional phrase with clauses introduced by as, use auxiliary verbs that cannot properly be completed by any part of the verb phrase in the main clause: neither have... did not begin nor did... did not begin is logically or grammatically sound.
这一点正是偶看不懂的地方，特别是受了下面这一经典例题的影响：
大全171：
Because young children do not organize their attention or perceptions systematically, like adults, they may notice and remember details that their elders ignore.
(A) like adults
(B) unlike an adult
(C) as adults
(D) as adults do（D）
(E) as an adult
从这题看，do not... do是符合语法和逻辑的。那么did not.. did...应该也可以啊！？难道说前后位置颠倒就不对了？不过就语感上来讲25题(OG91)好像是那么回事。
不过，暂时来讲偶只能接受把 Like 改成 As did 是改变了原句的逻辑意思。
另外还想请教大家一个问题：
若比较的前半句用现在进行时－are doing，后半句如果想用现在完成进行时，那么助动词补出是否可以只补出 have been？谢谢！
今天查到了关于OG91 NN们的解答 附在贴后 供LES参考 希望能有帮助
Weiyu:
like many self-taught artists.P did not begin to paint until she was well into middle age. 当用 As did表示只和until前的话平行对比，而和was无关；但是句子意思却要求反映这帮artists直到中年才开始绘画，这时不能补出２个不同的助动词，所以是A
我觉得OG说的很清楚，只有一个did不能代表 “did not begin to paint until she was well into middle age”
tianwan:
简洁性：如果意思同样，like+名词/代词比as+谓语简洁。
逻辑意思：many self-taught artists和Perle Hessing同样的范畴，应该是同样的动作， Perle Hessing did not那么many self-taught artists也应该did not，like就表明了这种同样的动作，相当于as did not 。而用as did则garble/tamper the meaning，表明Perle Hessing did not，但是many self-taught artists did。
但如果比较的对象是对立的范畴，如adult，child，则动作可能是对立的，也可能不对立。这时用like不妥当，要用as did或as did not清晰的表明动作的相同或对立。
敬佩MM的执着精神 相信一定会取得好成绩的
谢谢paopao!
抱歉，这两天忙着工作前的一些事宜，几天没来了，今天才看到LES的短信
我觉得第19题是因为时态问题，还有have错，have后面未必一定要接been rising的
25题E选项不好，我觉得是逻辑意思问题，和tianwan兄意见一样
171题，我觉得干扰不应该存于现象，从意思上来看，as adult do是表示和children的相反
而25题表示前者和后者一致，如果用as did sb1, sb2 did not说明两者相反
不知道说清楚了没有
祝LES考出N分！！！
若比较的前半句用现在进行时－are doing，后半句如果想用现在完成进行时，那么助动词补出是否可以只补出 have been？谢谢！
我觉得这样是否有主动和被动比较的嫌疑，因为have been后不仅仅可以补出doing，也可能补出done。这个问题好像在哪里看到过，似曾相识。
C的主要错误在于:as是连词,意为"如同",表承前相似,所以不能出现在句首,只能出现在句尾.
欢迎指正.
A) 根据XDF,Similar to 放句首错，similar意思太为广泛
B）还原为 as interest rates have been rising. been rising 前面出现过，故可以省略。 所以B对
C）还原的话，只能是 have rising,所以错
D）like只能接名词，不能接句子
E）as接句子，应该改为like
| 欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) | Powered by Discuz! X3.3 |