我觉得应该选C，that作price的定语，就是the price that the manufacturer charges for another product.
price of what总感觉有些怪。请大家指点！谢谢！
作者: tianwan 时间: 2004-6-28 17:39
Yes，I think you are right.
作者: 飒露紫 时间: 2004-6-28 17:41
多谢斑竹！！
作者: LES 时间: 2004-6-28 17:44
如你所说，那么the price在从句中做什么呢？
倍数+the+noun+of －倍数表达法之一。
作者: 飒露紫 时间: 2004-6-28 18:27
如你所说，那么the price在从句中做什么呢？
倍数+the+noun+of －倍数表达法之一。
语法方面的各种具体规定我也不是太清楚，不过我觉得that从句是修饰price的，price应该是做charge for的宾语，不知道对不对，请斑竹姐姐指正
作者: 唐三彩 时间: 2004-6-28 19:04
可是，中间断开了，That这个紧跟名词的限定性的修饰也许就不能用了的说。。。用Which应该可以的。
不过总觉得charge for的宾语不应该是price。。。。
作者: tianwan 时间: 2004-6-28 20:08
I am not sure. longman doesn't explain this "charge for" in detail. But a example in kingsoft, "charges ten dollars for a haircut", may lend some support to choice C.
作者: tulipmontreal 时间: 2004-6-29 10:22
当然是D
作者: LES 时间: 2004-6-29 12:06
charge 10 dollars 当然O.K.
但是，charge the price 就不对了。
作者: rt316 时间: 2004-7-8 02:08
charge 10 dollars 当然O.K.
但是，charge the price 就不对了。
很巧，刚看了这个帖子就在阅读中看到一个例子，63-9-Question8-D：Many directors of large firms believe that the government should establish the prices that will be charged for products.
作者: LES 时间: 2004-7-12 01:22
偶弃暗投明了。选C!
发现偶原来对of what中的of 理解有误，D选项变成the price of 另一种药的price了。
作者: oasis123 时间: 2004-9-24 17:44
我觉得the price 应该补在charge与for的中间
也就是the drug’s maker charges the price for another product
所以我选that (修饰the price)
选at which感觉上多了at
如果选of what, 也觉得多了of和前面的the price
因为what=the thing that
作者: killer34888 时间: 2004-9-24 20:48
og中强调，that.....for一定要变为for which
作者: ricky663 时间: 2004-9-25 21:36
you dao li
作者: comeby_j2004 时间: 2004-9-26 21:57
C有道理，以下是用google搜索到的一句英语广告，
The dealer's cost, or invoice price, is the price that the manufacturer charges the dealer for the car.
详细体网址见下;
http://militaryfinance.umuc.edu/cars/car_buy2.html
作者: 青鸟 时间: 2004-9-29 00:39
D
作者: lifelover 时间: 2004-10-7 00:48
到底选什么？各位NN有没有定论？ 我原来也选C来着，看了LZM倍数表达法的总结，已经同意选D了，现在又..., 哎，晕了。
作者: richard_zhang 时间: 2004-10-19 23:34
d也不错
GOOGLE: Too Expensive We checked, and their photography is TWO to THREE times the price
of what the local photographers charge, and their work is not better.
作者: apple01 时间: 2004-11-16 00:20
How about A? Why is A wrong?
作者: seekmydream 时间: 2004-12-8 10:14
The key is definitely C!
习惯表达方式: sb. charge (sb.) the price for sth -- the price 是宾语, 第二个sb 是间接宾语
所以就有 The dealer's cost, or invoice price, is the price that the manufacturer charges the dealer for the car.
the price = $10 之类
具体到此题, 就是 the price that the drug’s maker charges for another product with the same active ingredient.
如果选D, 从句的意思就变成 the drug's maker charges sth for another product
而不是 the drug's maker charges the price for another product
see?
作者: joe11 时间: 2004-12-8 10:58
Oh.... 原来是这样的。好，C 对。
但是 three times of what other manufactures charge 中间去掉the price，这种表达还是对的吧。
作者: littlemuddie 时间: 2004-12-8 12:01
A new hair-growing drug is being sold for three times the price, per milligram, as the drug’s maker charges for another product with the same active ingredient.
- as
- than
- that
- of what
- at which
我觉得应该选C，that作price的定语，就是the price that the manufacturer charges for another product.
price of what总感觉有些怪。请大家指点！谢谢！
我仍有困惑。不是that不能做非限制定语吗？还有，what从不引导定语从句? 不知对否？
请指迷津。
作者: cicilla 时间: 2005-1-16 21:21
that用于限制性定语从句，但是名词和that中间有插入语是可以的。
怎么还是觉得C也对D也可以啊，晕！
作者: anyname 时间: 2005-3-21 15:45
支持C。D中WHAT只能指代PRICE或DOLLARS，那么price of price/dollars，都很滑稽。
作者: billion 时间: 2005-5-15 14:07
这题怎么没人选 E?
上google搜，到处都是"price at which..."
作者: luxing 时间: 2005-6-9 10:15
同意E
作者: drunkbear 时间: 2005-6-13 06:55
支持C。D中WHAT只能指代PRICE或DOLLARS，那么price of price/dollars，都很滑稽。
完全同意anyname,选C
of what = of sth that, 因为题干中的charges,所以sth指price, 还原后
the price of what the maker charges for ... = the price of the price that the maker charges for 不合逻辑.
但是下一例句中可用of what
He paid the twice the price of what they got from that store.
=He paid the twice the price of the books that they got from that store.
作者: forjoke 时间: 2005-6-21 10:12
支持D
C：charge price for不通。
that应紧跟price
作者: huamei 时间: 2005-7-11 07:53
晕死,到底是啥呀?为什么参考答案不一样呢.三次出现,三个答案
作者: WalkByFaith 时间: 2005-7-31 07:20
obviously, it took one year to discuss this item and most of GMATers vote for C. NN, who can tell what is wrong with E since i'm not alone to ask this?
thanks.
作者: WalkByFaith 时间: 2005-7-31 07:23
up E!
作者: xulijun 时间: 2005-7-31 12:53
支持d选项 three times the price of sth, 而what 名词性从句就是这个sth.
作者: yayijia 时间: 2005-8-2 22:48
我认为the price of 后面可以跟一个价格
比如the price of 50 dollars
what 指这个价格
作者: 番茄笑了 时间: 2005-8-20 04:37
Q8:
A new hair-growing drug is being sold for three times the price, per milligram, as the drug’s maker charges for another product with the same active ingredient.
- as
- than
- that
- of what
- at which
这一题选择c我没有疑问！的确是c比较简洁也清楚！可是我做的时候两次都选了E。郁闷啊~不知道为什么脑子里总觉得price at which...charge for...是一种合适的搭配！有没有人能给我解释一下E到底怎么错了？谢谢。。。
作者: hcxdx 时间: 2005-9-7 16:02
同问，同问啊
作者: fatlara 时间: 2005-9-25 19:55
支持C。D中WHAT只能指代PRICE或DOLLARS，那么price of price/dollars，都很滑稽。
很有道理啊~~
相同的道理, E也是不对的: the price at xxx dollars, or, the price at price...
都是说不通的句子啊
作者: springflower 时间: 2005-10-25 01:20
我觉得是e啊
I think it should be undoubtable that the underlined word should refer to the price,then:
if c, than it means that the drug's maker charges "the price" for another product ... I think if it is "the amount" here rather than "the price" then c should be right
if d, than it may mean that "the drug's maker charges of the price for another product ..." it sounds very strange to me. I don't think the word "what" here should mean the product
if E, than it means that "the drug's maker charges at the price for another product ..." I think e is the best choice
but i don't understand why in the first half of this sentence it is said that "A ...drug is being sold FOR ..." don't understand why "for" is used here, but anyway we should focus on the underlined part and there is no "for which" choice
Pls correct me if I'm wrong as I now really believe E is the right choice.
作者: andria558 时间: 2005-10-26 12:48
In my opion, answer is likely to be B. three times ... than ...
作者: llrllrllr 时间: 2005-10-26 16:03
我选了E,不明白为什么错?请NN解答啊.
作者: llrllrllr 时间: 2005-10-27 15:54
没人理,再顶一下.
作者: kathy_yu 时间: 2005-12-22 02:23
A new hair-growing drug is being sold for three times the price, per milligram, as the drug’s maker charges for another product with the same active ingredient.
选C。
如选D的话，New drug is sold for three times the price of drug /product（但是后面不缺drug /product，实际上缺的是price）. 而如果补全后面的the drug’s maker charges for another product，应该是：the drug’s maker charges price for another product。可以看到原文的the price就是定语从句的先行词，即用that引导的定语从句！
作者: andy_rds 时间: 2006-2-2 16:29
选C 错，that 引导的定语从句不能被逗号分割，必须与修饰词直接关联
D 选项,change of price for sth, 我从未见过这种用法
我选E.
作者: andy_rds 时间: 2006-2-2 16:30
请NN们解答
作者: mxcc705 时间: 2006-2-3 11:57
肯定是D呀,因为要保持语意及结构上的一致,价格肯定要与价格比较,所以要用of+什麽product.
不要在所谓固定搭配上浪费时间.
作者: GMAT2006JJ 时间: 2006-2-3 12:54
that 引导定语从句的话, 在它之前无逗号. 而which 有.
作者: andy_rds 时间: 2006-2-3 16:04
我最终决定选 C， 因为逗号是对插入语起作用的，此处可以忽略逗号及插入语。
E 的选项适合于动词用sold, sell 等，此处是 charge，因此不能用 at which.
对不起，始终不觉得 D 正确
作者: wonglum 时间: 2006-3-24 15:20
我选了E，但看了楼上andy的解释后觉得C正确。将句子第二部分还原成正常语序就会看得比较清楚：drug’s maker charges for another product with the same active ingredient $10(举个方便的例子）.然后 $10 = the price = that.
不知道这样的解释是否能表达清楚
作者: mba06 时间: 2006-5-15 05:18
"what" the drugs maker charges is "price".
price of what the drugs maker changes = price of price
awkward.
The answer should be C. the price that drugs maker charges.
作者: trymeagain 时间: 2006-6-11 20:45
同意 c
charge 是及物动词，the price在that定于从句中作 charge的宾语。
作者: trymeagain 时间: 2006-6-11 20:46
如果用 what 应该是这样的，
three times what the drug maker charges for...
作者: Factiva 时间: 2006-10-17 20:22
It is funny just asked three native speakers, two chose B, one chose A. Ha ha 
作者: wanggump 时间: 2007-5-22 07:24
Q8:
A new hair-growing drug is being sold for three times the price, per milligram, as the drug’s maker charges for another product with the same active ingredient.
- as
- than
- that
- of what
- at which
这一题选择c我没有疑问！的确是c比较简洁也清楚！可是我做的时候两次都选了E。郁闷啊~不知道为什么脑子里总觉得price at which...charge for...是一种合适的搭配！有没有人能给我解释一下E到底怎么错了？谢谢。。。
如果选E的话，后半句就变成 the drug's maker charges for another product with the same active ingredient at 10$. 正确的表达应该是the drug's maker charges 10$ for another product with the same active ingredient.
作者: zard 时间: 2007-5-22 09:55
选C.
D 选项“of what",不管是the price of price that....; 还是the price of product that ....都说不通。
E 选项“at which". 我们可以说charge sth at ..., 也可以说 charge .... for ; charge ... for 就是C选项的用法。 如果要用"at which" ，那么句子里的for应该删除掉。再说charge sth1 at sth2. 这个sth2一般是rate或者是个范围，另外朗文里面关与charge sth at sth用的例句基本上是被动语态。
A new hair-growing drug is being sold for three times the price, per milligram, at which the drug’s maker charges
(for) another product with the same active ingredient.
作者: yyisme 时间: 2007-11-2 20:47
选C哦，我在new york times找到原句了
New Pill for Baldness: Old Drug at Higher Price
Propecia, a hair-growth drug, is being sold for three times the price, per milligram, that the drug's maker, charges for another product with the same active ingredient. Page D1.
作者: aircavalry 时间: 2007-11-14 00:31
楼上的mm真厉害……如果不是电子版的话
作者: lulu_odin 时间: 2008-3-4 09:32
太厉害了,NY times的原句,那应该选C
作者: shhai 时间: 2008-3-21 22:34
我也觉得D是对的，the price of what ..., 后面的charge 跟 of dollar 是比较合适的，charge 后面跟that ( the price) 就不合适了。
| 欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) | Powered by Discuz! X3.3 |