标题: 对一道GWD题目有疑问！！！！！ [打印本页] 作者: camelo777 时间: 2011-6-8 06:14 标题: 对一道GWD题目有疑问！！！！！ For many people, household labor remains demanding even if able to afford household appliances their grandparents would find a miracle.
A. even if able to afford household appliances their grandparents would find a miracle
B. despite being able to afford household appliances their grandparents would find a miracle
C. even if they can afford household appliances their grandparents would have found miraculous
D. although they could afford household appliances their grandparents would find miraculous
E. even if they are able to afford household appliances which would have been a miracle to their grandparents
C里面用的would have found miraculous 表示我们的现在和老一代年轻的时候相比
D里面用的would find miraculous 表示我们的现在和老一代的现在相比
E里面 are able to 是有能力；说实话我也是看它后半句不如c简单，我觉得它不一定错了，但一定不如c清晰明了作者: camelo777 时间: 2011-6-8 09:47
恩恩are able to确实不够简洁，既然有can，应该优先选can， 关于C和D我没看明白你讲的？能不能再解释下谢谢~作者: chelseeea 时间: 2011-6-8 09:55
would have found miraculous 讲的是爷爷们 以前 会觉得这些appliance很神奇，符合题意 would find miraculous 讲的是爷爷们 现在 会觉得这些appliance很神奇，但是爷爷们现在也和我们一样，经历过这些appliance的发明，不会觉得很神奇了作者: jameshzd 时间: 2011-6-8 09:59
我是这样理解的哈，你记不记得我以前说的一个句型啊：if X happens， Y would / will happen .这个条件状语从句不是所有只要是 if 引导就是必须这个句型，它是有限制的，首先 X 其实是没有happen 的，只是做的一个假设一个虚拟的状态，你看这一题，题意是 even if 即使，意思就是 even if 后面的事件其实 是没有发生的啊，所以句型： even if X can happen, Y would have found（household appliances ） miraculous (与现在事实相反)。 D选项，我一看 although 就知道错了，因为 although 就改变了文章的意思了，文章不是要表达尽管（尽管是说他们已经can afford household appliances ）的意思，而是表达 即使 （假设状态）的意思更加贴。 E which would have been a miracle to their grandparents，个人觉得用被动是很wordy也没必要的，而且也改变了句子的中心，原文章的中心是放在 their grandparents ，而 which 引导后，重心就变成了household appliances 了。
up。。。逼急了我去换个女号...换个美女头像...NN们肯定蜂拥而至....
体会一下我纠结的心情。。。