标题: 逻辑求助~ [打印本页] 作者: fengchen318 时间: 2011-3-10 15:24 标题: 逻辑求助~ 12.A study comparing a group of chronically(长期的) depressed individuals with an otherwise matched group of individuals free from depression found significantly more disorders of the immune system among the depressed group. According to the researchers, these results strongly support the hypothesis that mental states influence the body’s vulnerability(受打击的) to infection(传染,影响). Which of the following, if true, casts the most serious doubt on the researchers’ interpretation of their findings? (A) The researchers’ view does little more than echo a familiar theme in folklore and literature. (B) Chronically depressed individuals are no less careful than others to avoid exposure to infections. (C) Disorders of the immune system cause many of those individuals who have them to become chronically depressed. (D) Individuals who have previously been free from depression can become depressed quite suddenly.（C） (E) A high frequency of infections can stem from an unusually high level of exposure (曝光)rather than from any disorder of the immune system. 能不能帮忙分析一下这道题的逻辑关系。。。谢谢啦，我选E，答案C作者: sdcar2010 时间: 2011-3-10 20:18
Does E mention anything about depression? If not, E is missing the point.作者: fengchen318 时间: 2011-3-10 22:21
Does E mention anything about depression? If not, E is missing the point.
-- by 会员 sdcar2010 (2011/3/10 20:18:46)
弱弱的问一句。。。C怎么就对了？。。。。作者: sdcar2010 时间: 2011-3-11 04:36
This is a question of correlation and causation. When two events A and B happen at the same time, the possibilities are 1) A causes B 2) B causes A 3) C causes both A and B 4) C causes A while D causes B.
In this particular question, the argument says depression causes infection. To weaken this argument, C says infection causes depression.