ChaseDream

标题: 备受争议的og10-18-111 [打印本页]

作者: lr_winter 时间: 2010-12-4 23:35
标题: 备受争议的og10-18-111

讨论帖很争议的一道题，没有特别明确的解释，贴上我的思路。大家有同样问题的讨论一下！！
Passage 18-111

111. The passage suggests that in the 1920’s a company in

the United States was able to

(A) use its own funds to set up a union

(B) require its employees to join the company’s own

union

with little employee dissent.

(D) pressure its employees to contribute money to

maintain the company’s own union

(E) use its resources to prevent the passage of federal

legislation that would have facilitated the formation

of independent unions.

原文定位：
it was only in the early 1930's that federal legislation prohibiting a company from maintaining its own unions with company money eventually allowed the Brotherhood to become recognized as the porters' representative.

这题很有争议：我提出我的观点，请大家指点，闲帖长的只看综述就好，看下这两点思路对吗？

综述：问题一prohibiting是现在分词，表示与主句动作allow同时发生

问题二:prohibiting the....maintain its own union中的这个union不是brotherhood而是和第二段谈obstacle中的那个union一个东东，即是和brotherhood对着干的。

详细解释如下：

首先，答案应该是没问题，而且能够从这句中推出federal law之前是不存在的。

it was only in the early 1930's that federal legislation allowed the Brotherhood to become recognized as the porters' representative.开始时困惑于og的解释：Lines 34-38 indicate that in the early 1930’s it became illegal for a company——也就是说og说federal legislation是1930s出现的，我开始理解成了federal legislation是1930年前很早就存在，而且prohibit company from maintaining its union，但从1930之后eventually allowed union存在了。刚好与og说的意思相反。

后来发现时语法上的错误导致了理解偏差。

这个修饰语prohibiting a company from maintaining its own unions with company money用的是现在分词，表示prohibiting和主句的动作allowed时同一时间发生的，而如果在allowed前发生必然用过去完成时(最好还加个the)，即it was only in the early 1930's that the federal legislation that had prohibited.....eventually allowed....to......

其次，很关键一点在于这个union很误导人，它不是指Brotherhood吧，而是和第二段谈obstacle出现的那个union是一个东东，是和brotherhood对立的东东【An additional obstaclewas the union that Pullman itself had formed, whichweakened supportamong Black workers for anindependent entity.】

所以，正确翻译过来我觉得是，在1930's前期有个federal legislation 出现了，它最终允许了brotherhood的成立，而这个legislation还有个特点就是同时prohibit公司用自己的资金建立its own union

欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/)