ChaseDream

标题: 你们是如何在不知道正确答案的情况下，看出句子要表达的是什么的呢？以A选项吗？ [打印本页]
作者: jbc88    时间: 2010-10-21 15:32
标题: 你们是如何在不知道正确答案的情况下，看出句子要表达的是什么的呢？以A选项吗？
RT
作者: jbc88    时间: 2010-10-21 19:26
额。。举个例子吧。

Although people in France consume fatty foods at a rate comparable to the United States, their death rates from heart disease are far lower in France.

A.    people in France consume fatty foods at a rate comparable to the United States , their
B.    people in France and the United States consume fatty foods at about the same rate, the
C.    fatty foods are consumed by people in France at a comparable rate to the United States’s , their
D.    the rate of fatty foods consumed in France and the United States  is about the same, the
E.    the rate of people consuming fatty foods  is about the same in France and the United States, the



DE为什么不能选呢？我看很多人都说不符合原意。可是原意是什么呢？他们指C。

但是这是个驳论，你是如何在不知道C是正确答案的情况下看出C是原意呢？你
作者: XXXXXY    时间: 2010-10-21 19:31
答案是B吧
作者: XXXXXY    时间: 2010-10-21 19:33
我先看A选项 一般情况下可以看出来
看不出来的 就看下面的选项 一般就可以看出来了 一般A选项看不出的A就错了
我做了好几道这样的
作者: jbc88    时间: 2010-10-21 19:38
如果说A选项就是原意的话。

Rejecting the apprenticeship model of training social workers in philanthropic agencies, twentieth-century reformer Edith Abbott was convinced of social work education belonging in the university so that students could be offered a broad range of courses dealing with social issues.

(A) of social work education belonging in the university so that
(B) that social work education should be in the university, and that
(C) about the importance of social work education belonging in the university while
(D) that social work education belonged in the university, where
(E) of the necessity of social work education being in the university and

这题选B。这样的例子又怎么解释？
作者: jbc88    时间: 2010-10-21 19:39
答案是B吧
-- by 会员 XXXXXY (2010/10/21 19:31:06)



是的，DE错在哪呢？多谢指教了！
作者: XXXXXY    时间: 2010-10-21 19:46
DE主要是逻辑错误 D是food的rate，E是people的rate 而题目的逻辑意思比较的应该是people consume的rate
作者: jbc88    时间: 2010-10-21 19:55
DE主要是逻辑错误 D是food的rate，E是people的rate 而题目的逻辑意思比较的应该是people consume的rate
-- by 会员 XXXXXY (2010/10/21 19:46:52)



恕我驽钝， DE不正是rate的比较吗？

逻辑错误？能指出来吗？
作者: XXXXXY    时间: 2010-10-21 19:59
如果说A选项就是原意的话。

Rejecting the apprenticeship model of training social workers in philanthropic agencies, twentieth-century reformer Edith Abbott was convinced of social work education belonging in the university so that students could be offered a broad range of courses dealing with social issues.

(A) of social work education belonging in the university so that
(B) that social work education should be in the university, and that
(C) about the importance of social work education belonging in the university while
(D) that social work education belonged in the university, where
(E) of the necessity of social work education being in the university and

这题选B。这样的例子又怎么解释？
-- by 会员 jbc88 (2010/10/21 19:38:57)

我觉得说A是不是原意不是绝对的，通常句子只有一个意思，要看哪一个相对表达的最好就选 另外这题选D吧
作者: XXXXXY    时间: 2010-10-21 20:07
DE主要是逻辑错误 D是food的rate，E是people的rate 而题目的逻辑意思比较的应该是people consume的rate
-- by 会员 XXXXXY (2010/10/21 19:46:52)





恕我驽钝， DE不正是rate的比较吗？

逻辑错误？能指出来吗？
-- by 会员 jbc88 (2010/10/21 19:55:42)


D the rate of fatty foods，不是foods的rate，而应该是consuming foods的rate E的people错误，不是people的rate。题目表达的是两个国家在吃油腻食物的比例的比较  CE因为在表达rate对象时的有偏差就不好了
作者: jbc88    时间: 2010-10-21 20:11
DE主要是逻辑错误 D是food的rate，E是people的rate 而题目的逻辑意思比较的应该是people consume的rate
-- by 会员 XXXXXY (2010/10/21 19:46:52)





恕我驽钝， DE不正是rate的比较吗？

逻辑错误？能指出来吗？
-- by 会员 jbc88 (2010/10/21 19:55:42)


D the rate of fatty foods，不是foods的rate，而应该是consuming foods的rate E的people错误，不是people的rate。
-- by 会员 XXXXXY (2010/10/21 20:07:43)



是的，你这样只是在做DE和答案的对比。并未能说出DE何处不好。

如按照这个对比，DE错误就在他们做的是rate的比较。而rate为什么不能比较呢？难道是因为答案没有这么比？
作者: XXXXXY    时间: 2010-10-21 20:15
题目表达的是两个国家在吃油腻食物的比例的比较  CE因为在表达rate对象时的有偏差就不好了
看一下正确的B项 你就知道B表达的要比DE好了
作者: jbc88    时间: 2010-10-21 20:22
题目表达的是两个国家在吃油腻食物的比例的比较  CE因为在表达rate对象时的有偏差就不好了
-- by 会员 XXXXXY (2010/10/21 20:15:24)




我也觉得是2个比例的比较，

E不就是2个rate的比么。C没有。相比之下，似乎正确答案的B也没有吧。。B前面是people,后面是rate
作者: XXXXXY    时间: 2010-10-21 20:24
DE 项 虽然内容上有包含要表达的意思 但the rate of 修饰的中心词不对 所以不太好
作者: XXXXXY    时间: 2010-10-21 20:28
people in France and the United States consume fatty foods at about the same rate
at about the same rate 修饰整个句子 也就是people consume fatty foods
the rate of fatty foods consumed in France and the United States  is about the same, the
rate 是指中心词fatty foods 的rate  
the rate of people consuming fatty foods  is about the same in France and the United States, the
rate是指中心词people的rate
DE 都是有比较的 rate的对象错了
作者: jbc88    时间: 2010-10-21 20:36
people in France and the United States consume fatty foods at about the same rate
at about the same rate 修饰整个句子 也就是people consume fatty foods
the rate of fatty foods consumed in France and the United States  is about the same, the
rate 是指中心词fatty foods 的rate  
the rate of people consuming fatty foods  is about the same in France and the United States, the
rate是指中心词people的rate
DE 都是有比较的 rate的对象错了
-- by 会员 XXXXXY (2010/10/21 20:28:49)



。。。。您这是拿答案攻击错误选项。那当然百试不爽了。 = =

你也承认了该是2个比例的对比。而正确答案B不是。作何解释？

我能理解你想证明DE错的心情，可是，我觉得如单单从正确答案看DE的错，这和骗自己是没区别的。
因为，你自己都说了，句子要表达的是2个比例的意思。
作者: XXXXXY    时间: 2010-10-21 20:41
B选项不是吗 B选项不是比较吗 Franch and US 在rate上的比较啊！！
作者: jbc88    时间: 2010-10-21 20:49
B选项不是吗 B选项不是比较吗 Franch and US 在rate上的比较啊！！
-- by 会员 XXXXXY (2010/10/21 20:41:24)





那，BD都做了比较。D为何而错呢= =


people in France and the United States consume fatty foods at about the same rate
at about the same rate 修饰整个句子 也就是people consume fatty foods
the rate of fatty foods consumed in France and the United States  is about the same, the
rate 是指中心词fatty foods 的rate  
the rate of people consuming fatty foods  is about the same in France and the United States, the
rate是指中心词people的rate
DE 都是有比较的 rate的对象错了
-- by 会员 XXXXXY (2010/10/21 20:28:49)



D中的 the rate of fatty foods consumed in France and（这里会不会是省略了the rate？） the United States  is about the same
作者: easy2010    时间: 2010-10-21 21:00
the rate 是省略了吧  这种情况很多出现  lz做个比较专题看看



欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3