标题: 求助，请教NN们陈向东的逻辑题 [打印本页] 作者: qiqi2010 时间: 2010-8-23 11:28 标题: 求助，请教NN们陈向东的逻辑题 Editorial: Critics of nuclear power complain about the allergedly serious harm that might result from continued operation of existing nuclear power plants.But such concerns do not justify closing these plants; after all, their operation has caused no more harm than that caused by pollution generated by coal and oil-burning power plants, the most important other sources of energy.
B.Closing existing nuclear power plants would require greatly increased reliance on coal and oil-burning power plants.
D.The harm that a nuclear power plant is likely to cause as it continues to operate can be reliably predicted from the past history of nuclear power plats. 这道题的正确答是D。但我想问为什么B不对呢？作者: qiqi2010 时间: 2010-8-23 11:31
额，不好意思，题目忘打了。题目是Which of the following is assumption on which the arguement depends?作者: 2008115061 时间: 2010-8-23 12:12
B说关闭核电站 ， 和原文无关 ；其次 已经说了煤电站德 污染是更大的，LZ的B选项可以作为加强项，但不是假设。 原文的的结论是核电站不需关闭，用的条件是核电站放出的危害没有煤电站大，那么前提就是两者的污染是可以区分开来的，所以才能做比较作者: qiqi2010 时间: 2010-8-23 22:24
明白了，谢谢NN的耐心讲解。。