ChaseDream

标题: 为什么这题要用句子，不用分词后置定语 [打印本页]

作者: kkssyangyang 时间: 2009-10-25 20:01
标题: 为什么这题要用句子，不用分词后置定语

6. Many economists predict that the next recession, when it comes, will be caused by Federal Reserve action taken to prevent an inflationary upsurge that would result if the economy were to expand at an annual rate of three percent or more.

(A) taken to prevent an inflationary upsurge that would result

(B) they took for preventing an inflationary upsurge that would result

(D) they took to prevent an inflationary upsurge resulting（A）

(E) taken for preventing an inflationary upsurge that will result

答案是A，但是为什么不是c，我也觉得A很顺，可是一般可以用分词后置定语都可以优先于句子，是不是有if从句所以前面不能用动词引导？希望有一个可通用的规律或语法规则来说明。

作者: kkssyangyang 时间: 2009-10-25 20:53
是不是有if从句所以前面不能用动词引导？

作者: aeoluseros 时间: 2009-10-26 12:50
an inflationary upsurge that would result if the economy were to expand at an annual rate of three percent or more.
如果经济增长速度达到甚至超过3个百分点，通胀就会发生。
umm...定语从句和分词不仅仅在简洁上有区别。
定语从句比分词更具体，更表达得清楚，分词的话有一种固有属性的含义在里面。
既然这里面都已经有if从句来表达一个具体情况发生时，通胀才会发生了，那么就应该用定语从句。

作者: kkssyangyang 时间: 2009-10-26 13:02
其实后面有从句的话，就要慎重考虑要有一个主句引导，那么就不能用分词了，因为这样就使从句成了前面句子的从句了，会引起歧义，我明白了。

作者: EMINEM830505 时间: 2009-10-26 16:31
后面是一个句子，得用“that”,所以不用C

欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/)