ChaseDream

标题: OG 12 CR 第60题 [打印本页]

作者: wildsilence 时间: 2009-10-6 15:13
标题: OG 12 CR 第60题

Red blood cells in which the malarial-fever parasite resides are eliminated from a person's body after 120 days. Because the Parasite cannot travel to a new generation of red blood cells, any fever that develops in a person more than 120 days after that person has moved to a malaria free region is not due to the malarial parasite.

which seriously weakens the conclusion above?

C)Many malarial symptoms other than the fever, which can be suppressed with antimalarial medication, can reappear within 120 days after the medication is discontinued

D) In some cases, the parasite that causes malarial fever travels to cells of spleen, which are less frequently eliminated from a person's body than are red blood cells

答案是D,

看了错误解释我还是没弄明白，他说：C) The argument give no reason to postulate any significant connection between the discontinuation of medication and the issue of whether symptoms can persist after a patient has been in a malaria-free region for 120 days

为什么no reason? 我觉得C逻辑挺正确的，就是如果潜伏到120天之后，如果停止服药的话，还是会重新因为malaria发病。

请指教！

作者: 沉香屑 时间: 2009-10-7 14:17

按照C的逻辑，即使120天后再发疟疾，也不会有发烧这一症状，只会有“other than fever”的症状。如果该病人发烧的话会是因为其他原因，所以不削弱原文观点。

D是攻击逻辑链断层，因为该文的论证有一隐含的前提是所有引发疟疾发热的寄生虫都在血细胞里，而这一前提明显是无根据的。如果该线虫也会在其他器官出现，那么光更新血细胞是没用的。

作者: wildsilence 时间: 2009-10-8 09:00

ah...原来在这点上！拜谢楼上~

作者: ddworld99 时间: 2011-5-28 20:53
D：题目说由于寄生虫死了所以120后发烧不是疟疾，D说寄生虫没死，直接削弱了论据，所以削弱了结论。
C：other than the fever病症范围错误，而且选项说在药物终止之后120天内，题目说在去无菌区之后120天之外，时间起始范围也错了

作者: Hendy 时间: 2014-12-24 21:14
你就想啊，那就是超过120天的高烧是因为疟疾产生的，也就是寄生虫还是引起了高烧对不对？
既然在红细胞里的寄生虫是可以排除的，那寄生虫会不会通过其他方式留下来呢？
然后D不就bingo了么！

欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/)