ChaseDream

标题: 请教关于"A of B that" 与 "A of B, Which" 的问题 [打印本页]

作者: danwilson_gz    时间: 2009-9-17 01:36
标题: 请教关于"A of B that" 与 "A of B, Which" 的问题

A of B that ...

若that后是一个限定性从句的话,它修饰A还是B? 这种结构在GMAT考试中会错吗?

我觉得这种结构多少有些问题,不过要真要选这种款式的答案,我个人觉得相信这个从句在修饰A。

A of B, Which...

若which后是一个非限定性从句的话,它修饰A还是B? 这种结构在GMAT考试中也会错吗?

我觉得这种结构多少有些问题,不过要真要选这种款式的答案,我个人觉得相信这个从句也在修饰A。

请大家指正


作者: danwilson_gz    时间: 2009-9-17 01:41

一个例子

OG11th 103: (A) the development of jumbo rocket that is expected to carry....

                      (C) the development of jumbo rocket, Which is expected to carry....

                     对此题目,他们都是错误答案,但我想知道这种修饰的合法性及其修饰对象(若其合法的话)


[此贴子已经被作者于2009/9/17 1:42:54编辑过]

作者: adai    时间: 2009-9-17 09:58

同问,

我知道 A and B, Who 的话一般是错误的

不知道 A and B, Which 或 A and B that 也是不受GMAT喜欢的


作者: danwilson_gz    时间: 2009-9-18 02:52

自己再顶一下


作者: danwilson_gz    时间: 2009-9-19 11:47

再加上两个例子

OG11th-56 题干中:...a breakwater of rocks that would rise six feet above the water and act as a buffer,... 中间的that从句修饰的是breakwater 防波堤;也就是进行了跳跃修饰,that从句修饰A of B中的主词A

但是在OG11th-62 正确答案(D)中:...reduced the amount of phosphates that municipalities are allowed to dump,... 中间的that从句修饰的是phosphates 磷酸盐;也就是进行了就近修饰,that从句修饰A of B中的B

另外 OG11th-54 正确答案(E)中,the amount of grain (that) farmers will be allowed to grow...定从修饰的却是amount ,从句修饰A of B中的主词A

open to discuss...


[此贴子已经被作者于2009/9/19 12:15:36编辑过]

作者: terry_run    时间: 2009-9-19 13:57


IMO  X of A and B that does/do / X of A and B, which does/do

are both right expressions.

but you have to choose based on logical meanings whether 

1) it is "X" or "B"  to do/doese sth ( in 2nd expression)

2) "B" or "A&B" to do/does sth ( in 1st expressio). ...

wait for other comments..





欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3